Linked by Thom Holwerda on Wed 2nd Apr 2008 17:54 UTC, submitted by Almafeta
Features, Office "Microsoft's embattled Office Open XML document format received ISO fast-track approval after receiving support from approximately 86 percent of the national bodies that participated in the vote. ISO approval will be broadly perceived as a sign of validation for the document format which has received widespread criticism from technical experts and standards advocacy groups."
Thread beginning with comment 307772
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
ISO standardisation processes broken?
by irbis on Wed 2nd Apr 2008 20:40 UTC
irbis
Member since:
2005-07-08

FSFE (the Free Software Foundation Europe) points out that there have been many severe technical and legal concerns with the OOXML specification that have been raised by various parties:

"FSFE published its 'Six questions to national standardisation bodies' before the September 2nd vote last year. Considering the statements about progress made on MS-OOXML, one would have hoped that at least one of these questions enjoyed a satisfactory response," states FSFE's German Deputy country coordinator Matthias Kirschner.

He continues: "Unfortunately that is not the case. Issues like the 'Converter Hoax' and the 'Questions on Open Formats' are still equally valid. As the 'Deprecated before use' and 'Interoperability woes with OOXML' documents demonstrate, MS-OOXML interoperability is severely limited in comparison to Open Standards. In addition to these issues, there are the legal concerns that were raised by various parties."

FSFE vice-president Jonas Öberg:
Now it seems that ISO could be the wrong forum for standards development in information technology in general. It seems to work too slowly or too poorly to make the ISO brand meaningful in the IT world. We'll have to see whether ISO can repair its own processes enough to become a meaningful participant.
http://mail.fsfeurope.org/pipermail/press-release/2008q2/000206.htm...

Even ISO itself agrees, although from a different point of view, that "the Microsoft OOXML process was a near-disaster" and that the ISO standardization processes in general are severely "broken" and "need radical reform", like the ISO president Håkan Murby told journalists at a press conference. http://www.fsdaily.com/Community/20080401_ISO_announces_radical_ref...

Edited 2008-04-02 20:53 UTC

Reply Score: 5