Linked by Amjith Ramanujam on Sat 30th Aug 2008 13:50 UTC
In the News Linux guru and convicted murdered Hans Reiser was handed a prison sentence of 15-to-life Friday, putting a final capstone on a case that began as a murder mystery, and ended with Reiser leading police to a makeshift grave a short distance from where he strangled his wife.
Thread beginning with comment 328868
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
NO (RE: Comment by werterr
by aquila_deus on Tue 2nd Sep 2008 04:16 UTC in reply to "Comment by werterr"
aquila_deus
Member since:
2005-10-02

Death-penalty is not an eye-for-eye kind of punishment. It's just meant to end the violence.

You kill or hurt somone for anger - very unreasonable and illogical, so we kill you to prevent you from hurting others for anger again, because you have proved that you're not a rational and worthy human able to live with others peacefully.

It's simple. Nobody on earth should suffer the pain to live with murderers or violent bastards and worry that he or his families would become the next target.

Those who believe murderers don't deserve to die should be sent to live with them.

Reply Parent Score: 2

RE: NO (RE: Comment by werterr
by driftwolf on Tue 2nd Sep 2008 06:13 in reply to "NO (RE: Comment by werterr"
driftwolf Member since:
2006-11-30

Then how would you feel about having those who sentence an innocent man to die being sentenced to death? Including the judge, the prosecutor, the jury, and the "committee" that actually does the killing, because they're all murderers if just ONE person gets wrongly convicted and put to death.

There is zero evidence that the death penalty deters crime. Some places with the death penalty have higher crime, some have lower. There are other factors that correlate much more closely with crime rates. The people doing the crimes don't believe they're going to get caught anyway. Besides, in 2006, US states with the death penalty had higher murder rates (and increasing) than those without, even when the states are next to each other. Seems it's not much of a deterrent, and more of an "eye for an eye" revenge thing.

What the death penalty DOES do is create situations where it is impossible to correct errors in the justice system. It therefore denies justice to those who are wrongfully convicted, while not adding anything in terms of justice to anyone else. Even "confessions" are suspect these days given the widespread use of torture to extract confessions. Even some USA cops are using that tactic, and not just in Gitmo.

Until the justice system becomes provably 100% accurate, the death penalty is nothing more than the current version of a lynch mob.

Reply Parent Score: 1