Linked by Thom Holwerda on Tue 2nd Sep 2008 16:38 UTC
Mac OS X "One of the most frequently used Cocoa classes is NSImage which, as the name suggests, is all about displaying and manipulating image data. The imageNamed: method of this class retrieves an image reference for you - provided that you know the name of the image you're after. Many of the images that can be retrieved via the imageNamed: method have well documented names, but there's a lot of stuff in there that's not well-known. It's those images - including some for Windows - that I'll be digging into here. I shall also give you source code to a little utility that uses an entirely different mechanism to retrieve images used by OS X."
Thread beginning with comment 329012
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Where's the 's'?
by siride on Wed 3rd Sep 2008 03:10 UTC
siride
Member since:
2006-01-02

Don't you mean "Discover OS X's Hidden Artistic Side"?

RE: Where's the 's'?
by Thom_Holwerda on Wed 3rd Sep 2008 09:41 in reply to "Where's the 's'?"
Thom_Holwerda Member since:
2005-06-29

I've been taught in school, as well as at university where I actually study English, that both are correct.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apostrophe#Possessive_apostrophe

More specifically:

"If a singular noun ends with an /s/ or a /z/ sound (spelled with -s, -se, -z, -ce, for example), practice varies as to whether to add 's or the apostrophe alone. In general, a good practice is to follow whichever spoken form is judged better: the boss's shoes, Mrs Jones' hat (or Mrs Jones's hat, if that spoken form is preferred). In many cases, both spoken and written forms differ between writers."


The 'x' is an /s/ sound, and as such, it is okay to omit the 's'.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 2

RE[2]: Where's the 's'?
by Johann Chua on Wed 3rd Sep 2008 10:48 in reply to "RE: Where's the 's'?"
Johann Chua Member since:
2005-07-22

But OS X is pronounced Oh-Ess-Ten.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 3

RE[2]: Where's the 's'?
by siride on Wed 3rd Sep 2008 12:31 in reply to "RE: Where's the 's'?"
siride Member since:
2006-01-02

I was also taught to not put the 's' after s-sounds early on, and then taught the opposite (rather vehementently) later on in HS and college. From a linguistic standpoint, it really makes no sense to leave it off since "'s" is a clitic (that attaches to a whole phrase), not just some optional or irregular possessive suffix that goes on a single noun.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 2

RE[2]: Where's the 's'?
by Googol on Sat 6th Sep 2008 10:29 in reply to "RE: Where's the 's'?"
Googol Member since:
2006-11-24

the X can never be an "s" sound because ever since the release of OS "X" people out there are being educated that it is read OS "ten" that is the name of the product, not "OS X" literally -- and there is no "S" in "ten". Therefore the correct writing has to be OS X's (read: OS ten's)

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 2

RE[2]: Where's the 's'?
by achmafooma on Sat 6th Sep 2008 11:52 in reply to "RE: Where's the 's'?"
achmafooma Member since:
2008-09-05

Thom-- interesting article, but I have to agree with the other grammar nerds here. 'Mac OS X' is correctly pronounced 'Mac OS Ten' which certainly does not end with an 's' sound. Thus, the correct possessive is 'Mac OS Ten's' or, in written form, 'Mac OS X's'.

If the pronunciation was X (like the letter X), then either way would be considered correct. However, 'The Elements of Style'-- which is an excellent little guide on how to write well-- says in Rule #1 under 'Elementary Rules of Usage' to always end singular possessives in an 's, regardless of the final consonant. I personally follow the 'Elements of Style' rule, rather than the 'whatever you want' rule I was taught in school.

Using an 's in this case is probably the best bet, since there are two commonly-used pronunciations of Mac OS X (the correct 'ten' and incorrect 'X'). The 's is right in both cases; the ' is only right in one of the two.

Anyway, forgive us for nitpicking and keep up the great work :-).

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 1