Linked by Thom Holwerda on Wed 24th Sep 2008 07:50 UTC
Apple The situation regarding Apple's App Store for the iPhone is getting weirder by the day. Several applications have been rejected from the App Store based on seemingly dubious claims such as duplication of functionality (even though they didn't duplicate anything), or alikeness to default applications. Two such cases made headline news over the past few days; Podcaster and MailWrangler. The developers of these applications openly protested against these rejections, and apparently, Apple doesn't really like that. Apple now reiterates that rejections fall under the NDA, prohibiting developers from speaking up about rejections.
Thread beginning with comment 331251
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Not legiment
by Karitku on Wed 24th Sep 2008 10:41 UTC
Karitku
Member since:
2006-01-12

Atleast far as I know putting ND clause in e-mail without otherside approval doesn't make it legiment. Example: Lawyer sends e-mail to me and demands something, in the end of message lawyer puts ND clause. Now I can freely post that message since I never agreed on that NDA. Atleast in Finland, dunno America. Does Apple demand NDA when you post them applications?

Reply Score: 1

RE: Not legiment
by lelutin on Wed 24th Sep 2008 13:03 in reply to "Not legiment"
lelutin Member since:
2008-07-17

If your app is rejected, then you have no more contract with the apple store for this app. am I mistaken?
If so, the NDA is not legitimate because NDAs apply in the context of a contract.

Reply Parent Score: 1

RE[2]: Not legiment
by rrife on Wed 24th Sep 2008 13:12 in reply to "RE: Not legiment"
rrife Member since:
2006-12-12

Your "contract" was with the development of the application via the SDK and whether or not it is allowed on the App Store is irrelevant.

Reply Parent Score: 2

RE: Not legiment
by rrife on Wed 24th Sep 2008 13:10 in reply to "Not legiment"
rrife Member since:
2006-12-12

I'm pretty sure the first agreement you have to acknowledge and agree to states that you'll follow any rules they make up after the fact.

Reply Parent Score: 1