Linked by David Adams on Sun 5th Oct 2008 02:58 UTC
Windows Windows XP just refuses to die. Have you ever notice that in movies they hit the bad guy just hard enough to stun him, then go about their business with their back turned to him while he slowly gets up and surprises them by attacking again? In this allegory, Microsoft management is the cute couple and XP is the villain: "Microsoft's deadline for allowing OEMs to sell PCs with systems that are "downgraded" from Windows Vista to XP is still a moving target. Initially planned to expire on June 30 of this year, Microsoft at first granted an extension to July 31. However, OEMs are still selling the downgrade option (often for a premium) and, according to new reports, the deadline apparently has been officially extended for six more months to January 31, 2009. The information is based on one leaked email sent to an OEM."
Thread beginning with comment 332421
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE: run XP on Vista
by flanque on Sun 5th Oct 2008 08:27 UTC in reply to "run XP on Vista"
flanque
Member since:
2005-12-15

Another interim method would be to run windows XP under Vista until MS finally fix the drivers compatibility problems in Vista


Microsoft fixes the driver compatibility problems? How about the hardware vendors fix their own driver problems?

The things people will try to blame Microsoft for never ceases to amaze me.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 5

RE[2]: run XP on Vista
by Bleistift on Sun 5th Oct 2008 08:43 in reply to "RE: run XP on Vista"
Bleistift Member since:
2007-05-18

What driver problems? For my PC Vista has better driver support than XP. And its more reliable. The only driver that sucks is the ATI driver for my Radeon card, but even that is better on Vista, as Vista just restarts the graphics-subsystem when the graphics driver crashes (just a flickering screen for a moment). Windows XP shows me a bluescreen and all work is lost.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 3

RE[3]: run XP on Vista
by REM2000 on Sun 5th Oct 2008 11:25 in reply to "RE[2]: run XP on Vista"
REM2000 Member since:
2006-07-25

i was gonna say the same thing, windows vista only driver problem was with crappy video drivers from nvidia and the drivers from creative., who apart from the fact the beta of vista was in the public domain for such a long time still couldn't get their drivers togeather.

Creative are well known for being the slowest when it comes to drivers for their products. Most of the drivers than were on the CD's for windows XP felt more like beta releases then finals.

I would say that the only problems vista suffered at the begining was that some of the newer tech introduced was a little rough (i.e. new file copying routines, network copying and some memory management).

I use Mac OSX at home and Vista at work. At the beginning i wasn't to impressed with vista, however the various updates and SP1 as polished it off. It's now quicker and more hard wearing, which i know is a weird term which ill explain. I use virtual machines, sometimes maxining out the memory in Windows XP and then releasing it, windows xp would still thrash the hdd after as if it was still maxed out of memory. Vista however seems to handle this process a lot better.

There are other things as well such as the impressive network speed when used with Windows 2008 server.

The only problem which still remains and will always be their is resource requirement. It has sacrificed being lean for adding features which is not a bad thing on today's desktop.

However on netbooks and lower spec'd PC's this is a major problem. Hindsight is a great thing, however this is not a critisim as such as netbooks suddenly came out of nowhere in popularity (i know that netbooks or ultramobiles had been around for longer, but these were very niche such as the sony TX Series and only used by a few due to high price). Microsoft could have repackaged XP as Windows "light" to run on lower grade hardware.

It seems that Microsoft are leaving open a market in which they are only plugging it with an older product, which is good on one side as XP works, is familiar and very matured/stable. However from a marketing/blog worthy side it's also pretty damaging as they still have this 7 year old OS out there confusing consumers.

The only other thing i would say in defense of Windows XP and why it's still about, is that Vista, apart from some small things (most of which are covered by third parties) it offers very little reason to upgrade from Windows XP on the business desktop. For example for my network i would have to purchase a whole set of desktop's just to get everyone to where they are now. Windows XP works well, it's stable and it gets the work done. If there was some amazing incentive then i could understand it, but there's little to entice.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 7

RE[3]: run XP on Vista
by flanque on Sun 5th Oct 2008 11:35 in reply to "RE[2]: run XP on Vista"
flanque Member since:
2005-12-15

Look, lets face it, there are problems with drivers in Vista. Is that Microsoft's fault? No.

Creative drivers come to mind from my own experience. I don't blame Microsoft at all. I blame Creative.

Edited 2008-10-05 11:35 UTC

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 1

RE[2]: run XP on Vista
by Morin on Sun 5th Oct 2008 13:23 in reply to "RE: run XP on Vista"
Morin Member since:
2005-12-31

> Microsoft fixes the driver compatibility problems? How about the
> hardware vendors fix their own driver problems?

And what if they don't? Microsoft would lose even more customers that migrate to Linux or OS X. The Linux people have tried pointing their fingers at the hardware vendors for crappy drivers, and it didn't work. I don't see why it should work for Microsoft. Customers are staying with Windows because it solves a problem well enough, but that is no longer the case when even drivers don't work.

> The things people will try to blame Microsoft for never ceases to
> amaze me.

There is no point at all in *blaming* somebody for the problems, since that would not solve them.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 5

RE[3]: run XP on Vista
by renhoek on Sun 5th Oct 2008 16:52 in reply to "RE[2]: run XP on Vista"
renhoek Member since:
2007-04-29

There is no point at all in *blaming* somebody for the problems, since that would not solve them.


but it does point out who should solve the problem.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 2

RE[2]: run XP on Vista
by bhuot on Mon 6th Oct 2008 04:04 in reply to "RE: run XP on Vista"
bhuot Member since:
2008-09-18

The way people on forums like this will cover for Microsoft never ceases to amaze me.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 2