Linked by Thom Holwerda on Mon 20th Oct 2008 15:58 UTC
Thread beginning with comment 334282
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
I agree, please remove this pointless restriction.
It's not pointless, as it serves a to prevent a previously very common form of abuse: post a comment in a thread, possibly inflammatory, and then moderate all those who agree/disagree with you. This abuse is now over.
Of course you can possibly still do it the other way 'round, but the point here is that trolls generally post first, and most often an opinion that hasn't been posted before in the thread (else it wouldn't be trolling).
This "feature", while understandably annoying, serves a very good purpose.
and then moderate all those who agree/disagree with you.
Is that a real concern? Each person can still only vote once per comment, and each member has a limited number of votes allowed.
Personally, I'd be more likely to vote Up someone who took the time to reply to my comment, even if they were disagreeing.
This abuse is now over.
What is preventing a person from getting more than one osnews login and use one to start flames and the other to fuel them? What's preventing people from teaming up to do this?
This "feature", while understandably annoying, serves a very good purpose.
I disagree, it serves no practical purpose. You're just making things more frustrating for serious users while the bad apples can get around the restriction easily.







Member since:
2005-08-18
I agree, please remove this pointless restriction.
So many times I've made a post, read some more comments and said to myself "Hey, this is a good point, I should mod this up" (not necessarily something I agree with, but a good point anyway), and found out that I cant since I already commented.
There's no correlation between making a comment and not being able to distinguish a good point from a bad one.