To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Optical chips? Pah! Everybody knows the future lies with Atom Chips! http://www.osnews.com/story/13216/What_About_Atom_Chip_
Sorry for the pessimism.
Correct. You're not a physicist. Your skepticism could have been and most certainly has been the same skepticism since we discovered electronconductivity across the entire Periodic Table, let alone across the varying types of crystalline lattice structures that Material Science Engineering and Physical Chemistry continue to develop/understand that sits dormant in plain sight.
Well I am a physicist, an optical physicist in fact and I can tell you that all this talk of optical computers is pretty much rubbish. The effect these guys discovered is quite nice, and might even be useful, however, we are not going to use it in optical computers. There might be a need for doing some logic all optical, but optical computers are a step back not forward, both in terms of power consumption and size. In order to do all-optical logic, you need powers in at least the milliwatt range, compared to nano or subnano Watts for electronic logic. Secondly, the size, waveguides for light are a few micrometres in diameter, have fun building a chip from that.
Generally, all this talk about optical computers is sensationalism.
Cheers
Jochen





Member since:
2007-02-22
I'm not a physicist, but when looking over this article, some of the physics seemed off to me... that plus seeing one or two of the classic signs of charlatanism make me wonder.
Sorry for the pessimism.