To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Not if they differentiate the products well enough. for example the netbook will have a 9" screen, a small solid state hard drive and a slower processor. That in itself should be enough to differentiate the products.
I'd imagine that for every cannibalized macbook sale, they'll get at least one customer buying their first/only Apple laptop or a an existing apple customer buying a second laptop. I have no interest in buying a macbook, but would definitely be in the market for an Apple netbook.
Which is exactly the point. Apple wouldn't have to be cheap, they sell on the brand name. You don't buy Gucci because of the quality, you buy it because it is Gucci. It is by no means crap but you an easily get the same or better quality cheaper with other brands. No matter if we like it or not, brand names sell products.
By that stretch of logic, brandless OEM netbooks would have led the market. Instead, more expensive Netbooks from Asus, VIA, MSI, Acer and the like seems to be leading the way.
The Netbook market isn't completely price sensitive. It's just a different market - light, highly-portable, small laptops with a small price tag. Because of that, Apple has a competitive advantage here, having a strong brand (notice, for the likes of EeePC, MSI Wind, etc., the netbooks were better designed, aesthetically, than their larger, fully-equipped cousins).
Secondly, Linux seems to be somewhat successful in the Netbook segment, but extremely so in comparison with Linux on desktops and laptops. It shows the market is willing to accept a non-Windows system in this segment, as long it performs basic functions consumers want (web browsing, email, basic productivity software). Something OS X can easily fill, especially with a much faster Snow Leopard.
Right now, netbooks are undifferentiable from each other, something very much akin to the MP3 player market when iPod entered. I think Apple can be very successful in this market, and with its brand, I think they could easily get away with higher margins than Asus or MSI.





Member since:
2006-05-19
Apple cannot win in this effort. They cannot/will not sell a netbook around the same price as a lot of the current models ($500 range). I would expect something around $750 -$800. All this will do is cannibalize their low end macbooks. The best thing Apple could do is to stay out of the market.