Linked by Thom Holwerda on Wed 24th Dec 2008 20:49 UTC, submitted by judgen
Thread beginning with comment 341453
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE[4]: I was too quick to judge Psystar in the past...
by Thom_Holwerda on Thu 25th Dec 2008 10:24
in reply to "RE[3]: I was too quick to judge Psystar in the past..."
A question in court could be if this right is included...
This case is actually really simple, and boils down to two simple questions:
I) Are 3rd parties allowed to resell legally purchased copies of Mac OS X?
II) Is Apple allowed to cripple its software to force people into buying its hardware?
Every other complaint flying back and forth between the two companies has to do with either of these two questions. Boiling it down to these very essences, any sincere and just court would rule in favour of PsyStar, and the general consumer.
RE[5]: I was too quick to judge Psystar in the past...
by Loki_999 on Thu 25th Dec 2008 10:40
in reply to "RE[4]: I was too quick to judge Psystar in the past..."
RE[5]: I was too quick to judge Psystar in the past...
by alcibiades on Fri 26th Dec 2008 08:52
in reply to "RE[4]: I was too quick to judge Psystar in the past..."
I) Are 3rd parties allowed to resell legally purchased copies of Mac OS X?
Of course they are. Are 3rd parties allowed to resell legally purchased Fords? Of course. Random House books? MS Windows retail copies? Of course. Copies of the NY Times? Of course! Is anyone really going to argue that OSX is the only thing you cannot sell second hand once you've legally bought it? Is there some special Act of Congress that makes it unlawful?




Member since:
2006-10-08
The following question could be: Has PsyStar the right to distribute / re-sell mac OS X? It's obvious that they got it from Apple by paying for it, so it's not a pirated copy they offer. As it has been mentioned before, it's valid to say that the customer pays for Mac OS X through PsyStar. A question in court could be if this right is included...