Linked by Thom Holwerda on Wed 18th Feb 2009 23:28 UTC
Editorial Does Windows 7 contain more DRM than Windows Vista? Does Windows 7 limit you from running cracked applications, and will it open the firewall specifically for applications that want to check if they're cracked or not? Does it limit the audio recording capabilities? According to a skimp and badly written post on Slashdot, it does. The Slashdot crowd tore the front page item apart - and rightfully so.
Thread beginning with comment 349757
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
lemur2
Member since:
2007-02-17

Here's one: http://www.osnews.com/thread?346846 "Debatable. Very debatable. Using Vista, try to rip a track from a CD you have legally purchased to .mp3 (without any DRM) and send it to your friend who does not run Vista (say runs a Mac or Linux box). See if you can do it so that your friend can hear the result.
"

What is wrong with that?

I don't use Vista, and that was an operation that someone had asked me about. That person had claimed they couldn't make a .mp3 file using Vista on their laptop that would play in their car, yet they were able to do that using XP.

Also, someone else had sent me a file that they had ripped using Vista that did have DRM on it (but that one was WMA). As I don't use Vista ... I couldn't verify how these users had managed to use it to rip something and end up with unplayable files (of which DRM was the cause at least once) ... hence the need to get people to try it for themselves.

... as it turns out, there is a dialog box that you have to uncheck an option if you don't want DRM on your WMA files after you rip them.

Edited 2009-02-19 05:17 UTC

Reply Parent Score: 6

WorknMan Member since:
2005-11-13

... as it turns out, there is a dialog box that you have to uncheck an option if you don't want DRM on your WMA files after you rip them.


In this case, you are speaking about a specific application, Windows Media Player.

There are dozens of different apps out there (yes, even free ones) that allow you to rip DRM-less audio files, in pretty much whatever format you choose. There's nothing inherent in Vista that prevents you from doing this.

Reply Parent Score: 1

lemur2 Member since:
2007-02-17

"... as it turns out, there is a dialog box that you have to uncheck an option if you don't want DRM on your WMA files after you rip them.


In this case, you are speaking about a specific application, Windows Media Player.

There are dozens of different apps out there (yes, even free ones) that allow you to rip DRM-less audio files, in pretty much whatever format you choose. There's nothing inherent in Vista that prevents you from doing this.
"

This is essentially true ... except for the fact that Media Player is a part of the Windows OS. It is, as far as many people are concerned, THE way that one plays and rips media files on Windows.

However, I posted the text was quoted in this thread in response to an earlier post in the earlier thread where someone had asked "how does Vista DRM affect end users"?

Even though I don't use Vista, I knew through indirect experience of two occasions where end users had been frustrated by Vista handling off media files, and that at least one of those was directly due to the DRM. The fact that there are many ways that knowledgeable end users can get around the DRM in these cases does not in any way invalidate the point that it had frustrated those users ...

I would also bring up the point ... why on earth would an end user ever WANT to apply DRM to a media file they had ripped?

Reply Parent Score: 4