Linked by Thom Holwerda on Sat 28th Feb 2009 11:47 UTC
Thread beginning with comment 351099
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE: The emperor's clothes fail to exist once again
by dragossh on Sat 28th Feb 2009 21:40
in reply to "The emperor's clothes fail to exist once again"
- OS X window controls are basically o , o and o.
They are colored. After you hover over them, you know what each one does.
- iPod and iTunes have an o that means you have not started to listen a podcast marked with it. Not that it says so anywhere.
Logic says so. You wouldn't mark with an o a podcast that was already listened to, would you?
- The sort of slider with two positions for on and off I have seen on iPhone and OS X makes it pretty much impossible to to tell if it is on or off.
I think a lot of people can tell quite well. When it says Off it's off and when it says On (and it even turns blue) it's on. What's so hard to grasp?
- Dock. No matter who implements it, it sucks.
It's quite good in my opinion, maybe you're just accustomed to the taskbar. A Windows 7-like Dock would be neat though.
RE[2]: The emperor's clothes fail to exist once again
by zima on Thu 5th Mar 2009 12:40
in reply to "RE: The emperor's clothes fail to exist once again"
"- OS X window controls are basically o , o and o.
They are colored. After you hover over them, you know what each one does.
"
Just got me thinking...while personally I don't have particularly anything against this setup, what about people that are colour-blind to one degree or another?
BTW - I'd like to have a mainstream, polished interface that depends on colour as little as possible, is mostly just neutral b&w (or perhaps a toggle switch that does that, also with, for example, activating some user style in the browser that assures things will remain contrasted)
RE: The emperor's clothes fail to exist once again
by stooovie on Sat 28th Feb 2009 23:07
in reply to "The emperor's clothes fail to exist once again"
One corner resizing in OSX is an abomination of UI design. Amount of resize/move/resize again is unbearable, even more so in a floating windows paradigm that is so central to OSX window management.
Is there an utility that allows users to resize OSX windows from all sides and corners?
RE[2]: The emperor's clothes fail to exist once again
by thebackwash on Sun 1st Mar 2009 00:22
in reply to "RE: The emperor's clothes fail to exist once again"
Yes. It's called NuclearMouse. http://628weeks.com/projects/NuclearMouse/ You might also try MondoMouse, http://www.atomicbird.com/mondomouse or WindowDragon http://windowdragon.sourceforge.net/
Personally, I like MondoMouse the best. You can resize w/o clicking.





Member since:
2007-07-01
Simultaneously screwing up two well established interface components because Google did it?
I can understand the reasoning that in a browser title bar and tab title are sort of redundant, but instead of making title bar a tab bar, there should be an option to get rid of the title bar.
It is interesting how supposedly artsy and usability savvy Apple keeps making stupid OS interface decisions:
- OS X window controls are basically o , o and o.
- iPod and iTunes have an o that means you have not started to listen a podcast marked with it. Not that it says so anywhere.
- The sort of slider with two positions for on and off I have seen on iPhone and OS X makes it pretty much impossible to to tell if it is on or off.
- Resizing from only one corner. WTF?
- The global menubar is good according to Fitt's Law, but absolutely wrong considering Gestalt Laws and despicable MODALITY it brings.
- Dock. No matter who implements it, it sucks.
I could go on, but I'll just end by saying that Apple hardware design is way better than their software interface design.