To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Yup I was a windy there. I agree Psystar is not even remotely OSS, I suspect that they are playing the the whole F/OSS sentiment with a fist in a velvet glove. There is very little case to be made for SW transfer after sale. My view (as a developer) is similar to Wil Shipley - of delicious monster. As a matter of fact I prefer F/OSS in the workplace. I Like not having to reinvent the wheel and having the option to learn from someone else's well written code. That is OUR dog in this fight. We can learn and give back - it is a positive feedback loop. Much SW for the Mac is hella overpriced (like photoshop and most of the music apps) and that is a negative feedback. It adds the price of another base model Mac to the cost of a workstation.
If However I was going to sell a copy of SW then I sort of have to give the disk serial number and box. Why would I sell an App or an OS if I planned on still using it?
I disagree that the the magic of Apple is select HW and SW integration the proof of that lies in the ease that Apple has switching the code base from Motorola 68K (in Many Macs even in 1995) to Motorola PPC 1994-2005 and Intel chips -- That seems like a large investment in well written code. Those are some hard dues to pay. That r&d is why I do not like why psystar is playing at.




Member since:
2005-07-06
All fine and dandy, but what has "There is NOTHING in the MacOS that the F/OSS software movement cannot replicate with some effort." to do with the case at hand?
Psystar isn't an Open Source company. They even use a proprietary license for their "retail hackintoshes". Although the case is about the validity of after sale license conditions, this doesn't mean it automatically is related to FOSS. If a license is deemed void, the software doesn't automagically become Public Domain or Free Software.
The magic of Apple is limited hardware support on preselected components, with a pretty UI on top of their UNIX. This is also already available in the FOSS world. Get supported hardware and install/get-a-preload-with a nice WM/DE on top of a *Nix. Same result.