Linked by Nescio on Mon 9th Mar 2009 08:05 UTC
Apple Numerous irrelevant issues and feelings about them are ventilated in comments on the case. However, there are only two important issues. One is what the law is, the other is what we think the law should be.
Thread beginning with comment 352523
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE[6]: Whose boat is it?
by GCrain on Tue 10th Mar 2009 20:40 UTC in reply to "RE[5]: Whose boat is it?"
GCrain
Member since:
2005-07-11

What you are missing is that Psystar is installing retail copies of OSX as an agent of the end customer. Should I be allowed to install Windows XP for someone without permission from MS? Same thing.


No, they are *including* a retail copy. They are installing a hacked version of their own, trying to side step the legality by saying that a license was purchased.

Should it be legal for me to buy Windows Home Basic hack it to Ultimate (on the same install media), remove Validation and install it as an 'agent' for someone else and profit from it? If Psystar wins, then it seems that it would be okay too.

Should it be legal to sell hacked software if the original was purchased and included (insert some copyright court case here)?

Reply Parent Score: 1

RE[7]: Whose boat is it?
by gcbirzan on Tue 10th Mar 2009 23:19 in reply to "RE[6]: Whose boat is it?"
gcbirzan Member since:
2009-03-09

Should it be legal for me to buy Windows Home Basic hack it to Ultimate (on the same install media), remove Validation and install it as an 'agent' for someone else and profit from it? If Psystar wins, then it seems that it would be okay too.

And the terrorists will have won! Less FUD, more informed opinions. If Psystar wins, it just means that companies like Microsoft and Apple will not be allowed to dictate what operating system or hardware I run the software I bought separately. (Yes, you are not allowed to run Microsoft Office on any other OS than Windows. The Windows version anyway)

Reply Parent Score: 1