To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
I didn't realize Safari was open source. If Chrome is very good and shares the same back end rendering engine as Safari and FOSS does not "automagically" mean it is more secure; is your point that Safari is open source or that the closed source wrapped around what is apparently a solid secure rendering engine is broken?
Granted, no source is going to magically be of high quality. Peer review helps quite a bit though and I don't think that's something Safari gets and definitely not something osX gets.
Someone mentioned OpenBSD in a previous comment though...
My point was that while Safari and Chrome share the same (open-source) rendering engine, result is much different. Which was a variant of what you meant when you wrote that "Granted, no source is going to magically be of high quality", wether open or closed source, I'd say. Let's consider that a notice to people who would solve all problems by "open-sourcing".
Of course, Safari is not open-source.





Member since:
2005-07-06
Not true. There's a lot of difference if operating systems provide some kind of protective measure or not.
In facts, Miller didn't say Safari is weaker than IE. If you took time to read the article, he said that EVERY BROWSER has holes and bugs.
However, while Windows (to name one) has developed some kind of protective measures to mitigate bugs and security flaws, OS X didn't. And of course that matters. He also joked about the fact that if you want fast cash, you can just concentrate on Safari on OS X.
If I was a OS X user, I would take his words in a serious way, demanding Apple to introduce all those protections other OSes enjoy. He has a good example: Firefox on Windows is very hard to break while the same software on OS X was very easy to break.
For the records, he also stated that he considers Chrome architecture a very good starting point. The fact that Safari (which he considers the weakest) and Chrome (which he considers the strongest) share the same rendering engine is a good proof of what many people say: being open-source doesn't automagically mean secure.
Kudos to Google guys, whose first browser is already a very strong implementation (and you guys know that I'm a IE user...)