Linked by Thom Holwerda on Thu 9th Apr 2009 19:33 UTC
Graphics, User Interfaces We've all seen the early demos of something called "BumpTop", a sort of 3D desktop where files are presented as 3D objects with physical properties. Recently, the project moved from concept to product with the release of BumpTop 1.0. The big question now is: are we dealing with the next big thing in desktop computing, or just a gimmick?
Thread beginning with comment 358395
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Comment by Hae-Yu
by Hae-Yu on Mon 13th Apr 2009 17:29 UTC
Hae-Yu
Member since:
2006-01-12

I think this falls on the gimmick side, along with most of the alt 3D UIs I've tried. I don't see anything that adds to my workflow in it, but it appears relatively stable.

The only alt-UI I ever saw with any potential was The Brain. To do any dev work or system maintenance, you still had to duck in and out of it too much for it to be truly immersive, though.

As far as the MS Surface mentions, I think it can be useful for many situations. Not just resizing photos, but useful to enhance a lot of touchscreen workflow scenarios - tablets, ATMs, menu ordering, remote controls, AV controllers, video gaming machines (I live in Vegas, they're everywhere), any kind of kiosk-type device,... Most of these are forced into a sequential flow due to the UI limitation, but this can be opened up with multi-touch. Remember, the desktop isn't the only environment these things are used in.

Unfortunately, Bumptop's is and it doesn't do that well.

Reply Score: 1

RE: Comment by Hae-Yu
by Bill Shooter of Bul on Tue 14th Apr 2009 05:01 in reply to "Comment by Hae-Yu"
Bill Shooter of Bul Member since:
2006-07-14

Most of these are forced into a sequential flow due to the UI limitation, but this can be opened up with multi-touch.


Multi-touch isn't the only way to do non sequential flows in interfaces. And I would argue, not the best interface for gaming machines where the majority of the users are not young. But, what do I know, I only designed the interface on one video poker machine

Reply Parent Score: 1

RE[2]: Comment by Hae-Yu
by Hae-Yu on Tue 14th Apr 2009 15:54 in reply to "RE: Comment by Hae-Yu"
Hae-Yu Member since:
2006-01-12

That's why I said "most" and not all.

I think multi-touch, like 3D, would be an enhancement, in the same way judicious 3D has usefully enhanced the desktop vs using 3D as the driving context, such as this bumptop. Multi-touch isn't the only way to do non-sequential flow, but it is a valid tool, if used wisely.

I understand the complete context of your user environment - bar mounted units have drinks, ashtrays cigarette ashes, and/ or food trays set on them. People sit, possibly stand or dance, on them. You wouldn't want a stray touch to ruin a users' game.

However, I just wouldn't rule it out for every possible touch screen game that might come out (gambling or video gaming) and say it will never be useful based on a single context.

Reply Parent Score: 1