Linked by David Adams on Mon 27th Apr 2009 22:59 UTC
Web 2.0 The internet has heralded in a whole new era of citizen engagement and the latest innovations in social networking have just intensified the enthusiasm for creating a "virtual town square" where people can speak up, join together, and make things happen. And that's really happening! We're using the net to organize politically, communicate with other people who share our interests, and connect with long lost friends. But what about when people use the strengths of the network to undermine the collaborative process? You get tyranny of the minority. Update: Read below for an update on the bike-naming contest.
Thread beginning with comment 360794
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Online polls are not exactly polls...
by dimosd on Tue 28th Apr 2009 07:01 UTC
dimosd
Member since:
2006-02-10

I think the crux of your article was that online polls are so unreliable they are basically garbage. So, if you really want to know what people think (or want), I suggest you trust an experienced statistician more than a web designer!

Everytime I hear about an "online poll" I know it's either a misguided attempt or plain propaganda. Real statistics are hard and obsessed about little details.

The other part, about some people being more influential than they would deserve otherwise due to their popularity... I think this is the way things have been for better or worse since antiquity, at least in (semi)free societies.

Reply Score: 3

EsoX Member since:
2005-08-21

Hmm, I don't know if I agree with that. In Sweden where (some) banks are in league with the government and responsible for issuing electronic "identity cards" I would argue that statistics from polls where the participants sign with their "electronic identity card" is reliable, given that all other parameters are identical (or adjusted) to match a "real world poll". The only major source of error would be that a certain group of people tend to acquire an electronic "id". However given Swedish GINI and literacy coefficients that would not be very relevant.

-----
As an explanatory note everyone in Sweden (from birth) has a "personnummer" (think "social security number" in US) that follows the person through his/her whole life. Opening a bank account requires valid identification complete with "personnummer". Getting a electronic "identity card" requires an bank account.

Reply Parent Score: 1