Linked by snydeq on Thu 21st May 2009 22:55 UTC
Databases Fatal Exception's Neil McAllister questions the effect recent developments in the MySQL community will have on MySQL's future in the wake of Oracle's acquisition of Sun. Even before Oracle announced its buyout, there were signs of strain within the MySQL community, with key MySQL employees exiting and forks of the MySQL codebase arising, including Widenius' MariaDB.
Thread beginning with comment 364884
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
how popular are they really?
by kurenai on Fri 22nd May 2009 02:08 UTC
kurenai
Member since:
2006-01-24

I've heard a bit about the various forks, but how popular are they really? I'd be really surprised if even 1% of hypothetical mysql users had moved over. And really, if you're going to take the time to port over/retest your code to a new db/storage platform, why not just take the plunge and move to postgresql and reap the benefits that brings?

To me, the main selling point of mysql is simply that it's so darn popular, meaning there are tons of examples/compatible products. It certainly wasn't the technology behind mysql itself, which could claim only that it was fast, assuming you could actually connect to it as it might be crashing when user #101 hits your site.

On the other hand, maybe we'll see these forks go off and polish some corner of the code base, and then in 3 years maybe all the pieces will come back together again and we'll have a really first rate oss db with stored procs, good concurrency, acid compliance and high availability. OR We could just have that today and not use mysql/its derivatives.

Reply Score: 4

RE: how popular are they really?
by strcpy on Fri 22nd May 2009 09:32 in reply to "how popular are they really?"
strcpy Member since:
2009-05-20

In some way I agree with you.

As much as I respect Monty as a developer, I think his somewhat obscure actions in the past couple of years have just degenerated the product -- or perhaps more importantly, devalued the good brand that MySQL had in certain segments of the database market.

Technically MySQL was never that good in my opinion. These numerous forking actions will just push people towards PostgreSQL and other alternatives, I think.

Reply Parent Score: 1