Linked by Kroc Camen on Wed 3rd Jun 2009 21:07 UTC, submitted by Liquidator
Thread beginning with comment 366916
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
The problem is that you can't separate functionality from looks. A program that looks awful will affect its usability and hence its functionality. A program's appearance has an influence on whether the user thinks it feels natural.
That's a claim that may or may not be true, and neither you nor the reviewer back it up in any way. Sorry, I won't take the claim as truth based only on the authority of a random douchebag on the internet.
The problem is that you can't separate functionality from looks. A program that looks awful will affect its usability and hence its functionality. A program's appearance has an influence on whether the user thinks it feels natural.
You're confusing terms there.
Looks have little to no impact on functionality. Particularly when the looks in question is just a skin that's easily (like 3 button clicks in Opera's case) to change.
Looks DO have an impact on emotion and this can have an impact on whether a user finds the application natural. But this is an emotional response rather than a rational based on how well the application performs / how functional it is.
RE[3]: The opera logo
by StephenBeDoper on Thu 4th Jun 2009 20:31
in reply to "RE[2]: The opera logo"
The problem is that you can't separate functionality from looks. A program that looks awful will affect its usability and hence its functionality.
I call BS - usability and aesthetics are related, but not interdependent. Usability does not depend on aesthetics.
Take Forte Agent, for example - despite having one of the ugliest GUIs in existence (with earlier versions, at least), it's also widely considered to be one of the most usable and robust NNTP clients around.





Member since:
2006-10-23
Seems like the author is more worried about looks vs fuctionality. So it doesn't perfect with MacOSX. Who gives a hoot!!. It doesn't look perfect with Ubuntu orange either, but you don't hear Linux users whining. I care more about functionality rather than looks!.