It's time for another "OSNews asks" item. This time, I want to focus on something that I've been wanting to talk about with you all before, but never found the time for. The question is simple: which feature(s) from other operating systems would you like to see in your own main operating system?
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Member since:2006-05-23
You should see what Linux is like on a Pentium 2 box. Even with 2D acceleration, you can see every single redraw.
The annoying thing is, circa 2004 I was using Linux on a Pentium 2 machine, and it was pretty fast. Somewhere between then and now, things slowed down, and I'm not sure when... I think it might have had to do with the introduction of Cairo, maybe.
(Of course, back then I was a complete dork... And a Gentoo user. *shudder* )
Member since:2005-07-24
I was using Linux on a P2 for several years. In fact, I was using Linux even on a Pentium ("I"), 133 MHz. That was in 1999, when I started using Linux as my main OS. And it was perfectly usable. I definitely could not see every redraw. But somehow, I can see it now, in 2009, on a machine that's 20 times faster.
Yes, Cairo made GTK+ much, much slower. In fact, GTK+ 2.x was slow before Cairo, many people were complaining about it, but now in 2009 I would be so happy if it was as slow as it was in 2004...
And yes, Linux is getting slower and slower every year. And it's not only redrawing. For example, in 2009, I often have difficulties just entering text like this into a textbox on a webpage, because I'm using Opera in the Qt4 version and just editing text (entering letters, selecting text etc.) in it makes my CPU go to 100%, and every action can take many seconds when it's completely frozen... I didn't have these problems with the old Qt3 version. The kernel is getting worse and worse, too (jerky behaviour under load, heavy disk I/O in recent kernels kills interactivity so you can either copy files or interact with the computer, doing both is imposibble).
But this generally applies to everything GUI-related in Linux. Whenever I upgrade something important (distribution, kernel, windowing system, application framework, graphics driver, GUI toolkit, desktop environment, or even just an application), everything is suddenly 10 times slower.
Edited 2009-07-16 21:18 UTC
Member since:
2005-07-24
For Linux: I agree completely (except for Qt4, which is extremely sluggish on my Linux PC, too).
The lack of GUI speed is the most serious issue for me. Basically, it makes my 2.4 GHz PC look like a 20-year-old 386-era machine with Windows. Graphics rendering in Windows with no hardware acceleration is much faster than accelerated Linux graphics.
Plus my desktop is getting increasingly unstable with all the heavy changes in graphics drivers and other things. I've never had so many lockdowns that I have now with the latest and greatest X.org and other technologies.