Linked by Thom Holwerda on Wed 5th Aug 2009 00:12 UTC, submitted by rexstuff

Thread beginning with comment 377070
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.

by sbergman27 on Wed 5th Aug 2009 03:22
in reply to "RE: Won't even try it..."
RE[3]: Won't even try it...
by lemur2 on Wed 5th Aug 2009 03:38
in reply to "RE[2]: Won't even try it..."
"KDE 4.3 is released now. Windows 7 isn't.
Well... considering what's been passing for "releases" in the KDE world the last couple of years, I'm not sure that distinction is very meaningful. Windows 7 prereleases have been around for a while now. And while I'm certainly no fan of Microsoft, I do at least give them credit for having higher QA standards for release than KDE4 has seen. Even for Vista. " What has that got to do with which is emulating which?
How can anyone conclude that the one which was started design earlier, and is released earlier, is an emulation of the Jhonny-yet-to-get-here?
"higher QA standards"? Windows? Surely you jest. All that I need to say to debunk that notion is "UAC, privelege escalation and MS internal applets". There are many other things that I could choose to say about that, but that one will suffice to illustrate the point.
Edited 2009-08-05 03:49 UTC

by dragossh on Wed 5th Aug 2009 03:35
in reply to "RE: Won't even try it..."
RE[3]: Won't even try it...
by lemur2 on Wed 5th Aug 2009 03:42
in reply to "RE[2]: Won't even try it..."
"KDE 4.3 is released now. Windows 7 isn't.
And surprising enough, Windows 7 RC is more stable and faster than KDE4. " Nope.
"KDE 4 started its design before Vista was released.
But not before Vista was designed 
Debatable. Aero didn't appear in Vista design until late in the game (as MS was initially primarily concerned about things like DRM and WinFS, some of which still haven't appeared).
KDE isn't a complete OS it is just a desktop. It is the rough equivalent of Aero.
Oh, BTW ... are you saying that Windows 7 is the same design as Vista? Are you quite sure you want to say that?
Edited 2009-08-05 03:51 UTC
RE[3]: Won't even try it...
by segedunum on Wed 5th Aug 2009 12:13
in reply to "RE[2]: Won't even try it..."
Member since:
2007-02-17
KDE 4.3 is released now. Windows 7 isn't.
KDE 4 started its design before Vista was released.
If your suggestion that KDE 4 and Windows 7 are clones has any truth then I think you may be terribly confused as to which one is emulating which.
As to which is "messy" ... I'd personally give that crown to Windows 7, given the decisions made on UAC, whereas KDE 4.3 integrates very nicely with PolicyKit.
http://www.kde.org/announcements/4.3/
"The KDE Application Development Framework introduces a PolicyKit wrapper making it easy for developers who want their application to perform privileged actions in a secure, consistent and easy way. Provided are an authorization manager and an authentication agent, and an easy library for developers to use."