Linked by Thom Holwerda on Tue 4th Aug 2009 16:32 UTC
Humor Since I think we haven't been having enough fun lately on OSNews, I decided it's time we do something fun for a change. We all have our little pet annoyances when it comes to other people's comments. Fixed expressions or comment styles that annoy the living daylights out of you. Here are mine.
Thread beginning with comment 377386
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE[11]: First!
by HappyGod on Thu 6th Aug 2009 01:25 UTC in reply to "RE[10]: First!"
HappyGod
Member since:
2005-10-19

As for "than" vs. "then" -- I highly doubt you do actually distinguish them in all contexts, you just think you do (people tend to assume they pronounce things certain ways because of the spelling or the phonology of the word, ignoring the fact that what actually comes out is sometimes quite different -- for example, the 'p' in "spit" and the 'b' in "bit" are pronounced exactly the same in American English and some dialects of British English and elsewhere, yet I imagine that most people would argue that point with me quite strongly -- until I pulled out sound analysis software which clearly shows that they are the same (and if you remove the 's' from the beginning of the recording, you can clearly *hear* it too)).


No. Actually what you said is that using sound analysis you would show that they are pronounced the same. The links I sent you prove that they are not.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 2

RE[12]: First!
by siride on Thu 6th Aug 2009 05:06 in reply to "RE[11]: First!"
siride Member since:
2006-01-02

The links you sent me showed that they are pronounced the same. You perhaps noticed that two pronunciations were given for "than", a strong one and a weak one. The weak one is by far the more common since the word is rarely stressed. The weak one is the same as the pronunciation for "then". Therefore, most of the time they are pronounced the same. I argue additionally that the pronunciation of "than" in the strong case is artificial. But don't worry, this isn't abnormal. Most people now pronounce a strongly stressed "an" to rhyme with "tan" since it is spelled like "tan" and "fan" and so forth, but there is no etymological basis for that. Had a strongly stressed form survived* directly from Old English and not arisen from people's analysis of the spelling, it would rhyme with "tone", not "tan".

*The stressed form *did* actually survive in the numeral "one".

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 2