Linked by Thom Holwerda on Sat 3rd Oct 2009 19:07 UTC
PDAs, Cellphones, Wireless So, you thought this whole tug of war over iTunes synchronisation was over, right? The USB Implementers Forum slapped Palm in the face, and exonerated Apple from any wrongdoing. The thing is though, the USB-IF is pretty much a powerless organisation, so Palm tossed them aside, and fixed webOS iTunes sync in webOS 1.2.1.
Thread beginning with comment 387697
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
only fan boys care
by viator on Mon 5th Oct 2009 02:27 UTC
viator
Member since:
2005-10-11

My wife just bought a pre she tried to get her songs out of itunes i didnt work. Then she got the over the air update of 1.2.1 and it worked! She was happy she didnt give a crap how palm did it she only cared that they made it work. The ONLY people that are going to cry about this implementation are apple fan boys and a smattering of other geeks. Everyone else will just say wow palm is great they made my itunes sync work.

RE: only fan boys care
by darknexus on Mon 5th Oct 2009 02:59 in reply to "only fan boys care"
darknexus Member since:
2008-07-15

Everyone else will just say wow palm is great they made my itunes sync work.


Oh, sure... until it stops working again with either the next iTunes update or the next WebOS update and people begin to wonder just why the Pre's iTunes sync is unreliable. This isn't good for Palm's customers omatter how you slice it, it's as bad an image for Palm as it is for Apple.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 2

RE: only fan boys care
by Blomma on Mon 5th Oct 2009 04:16 in reply to "only fan boys care"
Blomma Member since:
2005-07-06

My wife just bought a pre she tried to get her songs out of itunes i didnt work. Then she got the over the air update of 1.2.1 and it worked! She was happy she didnt give a crap how palm did it she only cared that they made it work. The ONLY people that are going to cry about this implementation are apple fan boys and a smattering of other geeks. Everyone else will just say wow palm is great they made my itunes sync work.


Ahhh it's nice to see that the reality distortion field not only applies to steve. The fact is that your wife's itunes sync will break at almost every itunes update and you will have palm to thank for that. Fair enuf if you find this acceptable as a customer, but me, i would be pretty pissed seeing how apple has provided third party vendors with a perfectly good way to sync without breaking at every update to itunes. And as a bonus, palm can do it without giving a big f--k you to the USB-IF. But hey, what would i know, im just a apple fan boy.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 2

RE[2]: only fan boys care
by phoudoin on Mon 5th Oct 2009 08:36 in reply to "RE: only fan boys care"
phoudoin Member since:
2006-06-09

Because there is a limit to counter device-masquerading too, a future iTunes update will *even* break sync support of Apple *own* devices eventually.

In the end, everybody lose.
Wait, it's a déjà-vu, no?
Hum, can't remember where.
Nevermind.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 2

RE: only fan boys care
by polaris20 on Mon 5th Oct 2009 04:57 in reply to "only fan boys care"
polaris20 Member since:
2005-07-06

No, customers that have a clue care. How's your wife going to feel when her phone won't sync again? Blame it on Apple? Or does she just not care and want it to work?

Blackberry can do it. Why can't Palm?

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 2

RE: only fan boys care - nice shirt
by jabbotts on Mon 5th Oct 2009 15:34 in reply to "only fan boys care"
jabbotts Member since:
2007-09-06

That's a really nice shirt and I want one of my own to wear. I don't care that it was produced by underpaid pre-pubescent philipino boys toiling in unhuman work conditions. I want my really nice shirt.

Or, in other words, how a product is produced and made to do what it does can be very important, even if it's only the technology geeks (or human rights geeks in the example) that take any notice.

Your wife is, of course, not wrong for not caring how the magic was done by Palm. However, the majority of consumers not caring how the magic is done has lead to the restrictive vendor driven technology market we have now. We now accept synthetic limitations imposed on technology purely for business benefiting reasons not consumer benefiting reasons.

Edited 2009-10-05 15:37 UTC

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 2