Linked by Thom Holwerda on Mon 5th Oct 2009 20:33 UTC
PDAs, Cellphones, Wireless Ah, the tablet computer. For over two decades now have companies tried to get the public to buy the darn things, and yet, despite all the efforts, promises, analysts, and even personal involvement by Bill Gates, they simply never took off. Recently, the tablet has seen renewed attention - but will they succeed now?
Thread beginning with comment 387821
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
by Kalessin on Mon 5th Oct 2009 22:08 UTC
Member since:

As I understand it, there are plenty of artists who like them because it's easier to use the pen to draw than a mouse. In those kind of circumstances where what you really need is a pen, it makes sense. In pretty much any other situation, I don't think that it does.

Computers are designed with keyboards in mind. Unless applications are specifically designed in a manner that a pen is an advantage, then a computer with a pen is not going to be an advantage. And just because a particular type of interface might seem like it would be cool or useful doesn't mean that it actually would be.

I mean, for instance, take voice controlled computers. They sound cool and all, but for most things it would be a lot faster to type what you want and manipulate your mouse where you need it than it would be to tell the computer what to do unless it has some serious AI behind it and you can tell it something pretty vague and still have it do exactly what you want.

Tablet PCs are useful for specific tasks - like art - but I don't see them being all that useful in general. Personally, I have no interest in them whatsoever.

Reply Score: 3

RE: Artists
by gtada on Tue 6th Oct 2009 18:42 in reply to "Artists"
gtada Member since:

I agree. Tablets have niche appeal.

Voice sucks in most applications because it forces the user to be very conspicuous. All I know is that my office is unfortunately library quiet, and it would be very distracting to have someone talking to their computer. Plus I don't write how I talk.

Tablets seem to appeal to artists/designers, the medical field, and a few other applications. Who knows though, I see a lot of people using their iPhones like mini-tablets. Maybe the killer app has yet to be discovered.

Reply Parent Score: 1

RE[2]: Artists
by Eddyspeeder on Tue 6th Oct 2009 19:23 in reply to "RE: Artists"
Eddyspeeder Member since:

Same thing pretty much holds for hand writing recognition. What a pain.

Can Apple revolutionarize the tablet market the way they did the MP3 player market? I think the approach the article takes ("no one wants it, so why bother?") is a fair one. The way I look at it now, I don't want one. Apple sure must surprise me and have surmounted all the things that are currently known about tables. Not trying to be trolling, but the word "tablet" makes me want to heave, the way the word "vomit" does, because of past experiences with them. So like I said, Apple will need a real sharp angle to pull me over!

Indeed, I have a Pro that I love and it handles the media I want to use just fine.

Reply Parent Score: 1