Linked by Thom Holwerda on Mon 2nd Nov 2009 23:20 UTC
Thread beginning with comment 392521
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE[4]: I skimmed the article...
by Tuxie on Tue 3rd Nov 2009 14:35
in reply to "RE[3]: I skimmed the article..."
RE[5]: I skimmed the article...
by Laurence on Wed 4th Nov 2009 08:39
in reply to "RE[4]: I skimmed the article..."
Well, why don't you just try it for yourself?
diff <(head -c 100000 file1.avi) <(head -c 100000 file2.avi)
This will compare the first 100000 bytes of file1.avi and file2.avi.
diff <(head -c 100000 file1.avi) <(head -c 100000 file2.avi)
This will compare the first 100000 bytes of file1.avi and file2.avi.
Unfortunately I'm moving house in a couple of days so my DVDs are packed away - thus I can't rip and diff. (though if anyone else is able to perform this test then i'd love to see the results)
....So I'm going to have to take your word on the differences being there.
However, (and going back to deduping for a moment) if understood the article properly, then the credits don't have to by byte for byte exact as the dedup looks at the bytes themselves rather than the whole MB block of bytes.
Thus there only has to be enough similar grouped bytes for a space saving to occure.
So unless MPEG compression uses some kind of random hash to encode it's data, then surely the very fact that the A/V is the same (timestamp or not) must mean that there are SOME similar bytes that can be grouped and indexed?







Member since:
2007-03-26
I guess that depends on the codec used.
I thought many MPEG codecs didn't have a timestamp as such and used a form of encoding that allowed an MPEG file (be it a video container file or an MP3 audio file) to be chopped in to parts at any random point and each of the parts can still play individually (much like the myth about worms ability to be chopped up and each part becoming alive)
Besides, your point is only valid for shows that have a pre-opening credits teaser rather than those (typically older) shows that always opened with music and credits.