Linked by Thom Holwerda on Sun 24th Jan 2010 17:59 UTC
Thread beginning with comment 405840
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE[3]: that guy's speaking truth
by flanque on Mon 25th Jan 2010 10:56
in reply to "RE[2]: that guy's speaking truth"
RE[4]: that guy's speaking truth
by Fergy on Mon 25th Jan 2010 14:10
in reply to "RE[3]: that guy's speaking truth"
Yeah, and all those torrent sites didn't participate in distribution - they just provided the links..
Yep. Do you think that it should be illegal to provide information? I think that it should be legal to download as long as you don't ask money for it.
Software and content owners should make it easier to legally download than to illegally download it. They should also use reasonable pricing. Most people don't want to put in the effort of learning torrents, searching multiple networks and frequently failing to get a movie, game or program. They would much rather pay a reasonable amount to get it much easier without trouble.
RE[3]: that guy's speaking truth
by KAMiKAZOW on Tue 26th Jan 2010 02:24
in reply to "RE[2]: that guy's speaking truth"
RE[4]: that guy's speaking truth
by lemur2 on Tue 26th Jan 2010 03:29
in reply to "RE[3]: that guy's speaking truth"
"Mozilla doesn't distribute Flash plugins. Mozilla provides a link to Adobe's site when a user encounters a page with Flash on it.
Thanks for supporting the argument that Mozilla could just as well point its users to a website where users could download h.264/AVC codecs. "
Right now they could possibly do that, but the period for which the h.264/AVC codecs can be used for free ends at the end of this year, so there is little point.
Besides which, Mozilla's main point is not about the cost of the codec so much as it is about the ability for anyone to implement web standards.
Mozilla's point is therefore still perfectly valid even if end users of browsers are still allowed to download h.264/AVC codecs for free next year.
http://www.0xdeadbeef.com/weblog/2010/01/html5-video-and-h-264-what...
The Web Exploded on Royalty-Free
The web has always been based on the assumption of Royalty Free. In fact, participation in a working group at the W3C requires that any parties disclose and make available any essential claims on the technology covered by that working group.
But that’s just a technicality. The truth is in the tests: you can still build a web browser, spider, client, web server, image editor, a JS library, a CSS library, an HTML editor, a web publishing system, commerce system – anything that is based on fundamental web technologies – without asking anyone for permission. This is a fundamental reason why the web has spread everywhere. Because everyone had the chance to add to the mix.
It’s worth saying twice. Anyone can create technology or services on the web and they don’t have to ask anyone for permission to do it. This is why we’ve had billions of dollars of investment and a fundamental shift in the way that western society acts and communicates – all in the course of a very short period of time. The web grew up on Royalty-Free.
The web has always been based on the assumption of Royalty Free. In fact, participation in a working group at the W3C requires that any parties disclose and make available any essential claims on the technology covered by that working group.
But that’s just a technicality. The truth is in the tests: you can still build a web browser, spider, client, web server, image editor, a JS library, a CSS library, an HTML editor, a web publishing system, commerce system – anything that is based on fundamental web technologies – without asking anyone for permission. This is a fundamental reason why the web has spread everywhere. Because everyone had the chance to add to the mix.
It’s worth saying twice. Anyone can create technology or services on the web and they don’t have to ask anyone for permission to do it. This is why we’ve had billions of dollars of investment and a fundamental shift in the way that western society acts and communicates – all in the course of a very short period of time. The web grew up on Royalty-Free.
The web grew up on Royalty Free, and Royalty Free is the only way it can continue, and continue to grow.
Edited 2010-01-26 03:44 UTC





Member since:
2007-02-17
I have a hard time believing his comments as long as Mozilla continues to spread proprietary plugins.
Mozilla doesn't distribute Flash plugins. Mozilla provides a link to Adobe's site when a user encounters a page with Flash on it.
At one point they also provided the choice (on Linux) to install either gnash or swfdec as well, although I'm not sure if they do that any longer.