Linked by Thom Holwerda on Mon 25th Jan 2010 23:21 UTC
Amiga & AROS It seems like only yesterday, but in fact it's already six months ago. July last year, we published our review of AmigaOS 4.1 running on ACube's sam440ep motherboard, and here we are, six months later, and Hyperion has released AmigaOS 4.1 Update 1. This free update brings with it quite a number of new features, and since I still have the sam440ep on my desk, I could test the new features first-hand.
Thread beginning with comment 406127
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE[4]: Needs a niche....
by tylerdurden on Wed 27th Jan 2010 03:57 UTC in reply to "RE[3]: Needs a niche...."
tylerdurden
Member since:
2009-03-17

Way to completely miss the point...


Amiga as a system is a good decade (or two really) behind in SW. Nowadays, people can run all sorts of niche OS, which support far larger bases of HW (and most of them at a much lower cost than this PPC thingie), and in most cases the OS itself can be had for free.

Taking on the current market with an approach that is over 2 decades behind in order to offer technology which is over 1 decade behind... can't be construed as any sort of logical value proposition. Alas, if these guys manage to sell enough copies to sustain that half assed business model.... then more power to them I guess.


However, on a personal level. If I want to revive the old Amiga days of my youth, I can either spend a couple of bucks for a used one, or fire AmigaOS up on an emulator that will run faster than any Amiga would have ever done nativelly. And then satisfying my craving until the next time. I would most definitively not go out of my way and invest over $1K on a fairly outdated HW platform running an OS which in real terms does very little, and has basically no application support... and that at the end of the day, the only thing "amiga" about it is reflected in a few court order proceedings...

Edited 2010-01-27 04:00 UTC

Reply Parent Score: 2

RE[5]: Needs a niche....
by TheDAX on Wed 27th Jan 2010 09:13 in reply to "RE[4]: Needs a niche...."
TheDAX Member since:
2010-01-05

@tylerdurden
You are missing the point on all levels.
AmigaOS is a fun operative system that is now back on the evolution path, AmigaOne X1000 is modern albeit different HW that takes the concept of Heterogeneous computing at heart by offering a way of exponentially expand both Flops (via GPU) and Mips (via Xmos miniclusters) at the user demand (which makes it VERY Amiga, and by the way a big paper from Commodore's engineers about New Amiga developments after AAA, was revealed showing the X1000 was designed following those directives to the letter).
But the the biggest mistake is your vision of the market.

Hyperion is doing this for a niche they already know and cater for, so all that description of "how the world is today" is pointless.
And by the way, Joe Poor Average was not the first to buy an HD-TV, he was not the first to buy a PS3 (etc. etc. etc. etc.) he is the last, if ever.
But you should also understand that not everybody is poor, 1000 might sound a lot for many but they are peanuts for a number of people (in the geek world) that exceeds many thousands of times the numbers Hyperion is aiming at.
Those kind of customers will buy a machine for 1000 different reasons but "bang for the buck", as when they spend what they have in mind is "FUN" not "convenience".
They might want a system that is as custom and exotic as it gets.
They might want to be part of the re-birth of a glorious platform and be there first hand as it happens. They might want a peculiar computer only you and a few others have as they don't enjoy being part of the Borg (Dell/HP/Apple) or the People Republic of Netbooks and Free Open Source OSs.
There is people who get a kick spending 50.000 on a car, and those that get even more out of their 1000 purchase.

Edited 2010-01-27 09:28 UTC

Reply Parent Score: 1

RE[5]: Needs a niche....
by Steril606 on Thu 28th Jan 2010 20:47 in reply to "RE[4]: Needs a niche...."
Steril606 Member since:
2010-01-28

I think that AmigaOS and the "Amiga World" as a whole is just not for you.

You are right, at the moment it's hard to see why to buy a system like that for these kind of prices. But, you know what? Ten years ago I said the same thing about Apple users. Much too expensive hardware, for some elitist Media Agency dweebs.

Well, we know now, things changed.

Those dweebs persisted, Jobs came back, things turned around.

And yet, even these days I have discussions with people, telling me "why should I pay 1000 Euros for a Macbook Pro, if i can get almost the same thing for 400 if I buy a Windows machine?".

You can probably build your dream PC for 100 Euro, or our of some trash and put a freeware OS on it.
That doesn't mean other people are not willing to pay more money for their computers and OS.

And who are you to tell them what to do or not.

I am not in any way saying, btw, that Amiga will ever be a "force to be reckoned with again". Nothing is indicating this.

But, it seems things are finally getting a lot better lately, and that's what counts for Amigans these days.

So who are you to rain on that small parade?

Reply Parent Score: 1