Linked by Thom Holwerda on Wed 27th Jan 2010 19:45 UTC
Apple In what everybody already saw coming for weeks (months) now, Apple has just unveiled its latest product, a tablet called the iPad. Basically a bigger version of the iPhone, Steve Jobs presented the iPad during a press event in San Francisco. The most interesting news? It's powered by... An Apple processor, called the A4. The most shocking news? The price.
Thread beginning with comment 406417
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
ok device but not great
by REM2000 on Thu 28th Jan 2010 09:40 UTC
REM2000
Member since:
2006-07-25

I expected more from apple, not because of the hype but because of what they have done before.

Personally like it has been quoted on every forum that this really is an XL iPod Touch.

When Apple first released the iPhone i was amazed, it was like nothing i had ever seen before. The UI and hardware was a perfect combination and i could wait to explore all of the advanced features the phone had. With the iPad announcement i felt none of it. It appeared to me a rather lazy development.

Now a lot of other forums, people have said it's rather lackluster without really saying why.

The reasons i give is that, im sure first apple could have done a better job with the UI and the way we interact with the tablet. The iPhone OS and UI is ideally suited to the small screen of the iPhone. To me the UI felt really left out that they didn't try and could have really gone to town and come up with something pretty spectacular with the new screen real estate.

The second is that the OS could have been more functional, i.e. a full blown OS. When i do use this device i want to share files, i don't want to do it via email and syncing over usb. I want to be able to access network shares and perhaps have an SD card reader. I thought of sharing via bluetooth in a swipe (minority report).

Another thing i would say is that the device is also intended as an ebook reader, however i don't think the sony e-readers and kindle have much to worry about. As i own a Sony E-Reader with E-Ink and it's a real pleasure to read books on this device because of the e-ink. Now eye strain and readable in any light source (bright sun and low light). However i can't imagine reading a book on a device with a backlit screen similar to my laptop, browsing the web and email is fine, but to stare for a good couple of hours would give me eye strain. Again another thing i thought apple would really have put a lot of thought in, having something which could have it's backlight switched off and have a e-ink type / style to reading books.

I just really thought they would have put more effort into the device and really create the next iPod type consumer electronic (i.e. genre changing).

I can see where they are going with the product and the intended audience is not lost on me (i.e. a coffee table top computer). However i due believe it won't see in any great numbers and will be a project to group with the Apple TV. Where there is nothing actually wrong with the device, however the niche for the product is smaller than the iPhone and Mac markets.

Edited 2010-01-28 09:44 UTC

Reply Score: 3

RE: ok device but not great
by kaelodest on Thu 28th Jan 2010 16:05 in reply to "ok device but not great"
kaelodest Member since:
2006-02-12

The Only Thing,

I have not read a real review. Nothing more in depth than anyone could get from the Apple site. I am not one of the people that this is targeted to.(App Developer not Media Director) The real deal is how it feels in your hands. Is it responsive. Is it something that meets your needs? Can you carry it and get the job done.Think software. Is the SW that is on it going to matter to you.
One of the things that I have always liked about MacOS v. Windows is the speed that it wakes from sleep to the full desktop. It makes me cringe every time that i have to go through an airport or to a federal building with a Windows laptop. I will assume that this is at least as responsive as the past 4 generations of portable HW
Much of what I have seen on the web goes straight to Fanboys v. Haters. And even if you do not like the fanboys the haters seem a little weird.

Reply Parent Score: 1