Linked by Thom Holwerda on Thu 28th Jan 2010 18:09 UTC
Apple Yes, yes, I apologise. After Kroc's story earlier today, and together with this one, we now have three stories in a row on the Ipad iPad (sorry, I can't ban camel case from OSNews just yet). So, what are we going to do? Predictions? Criticism? More details? No - I want to explain what I think the differences are between the introduction of the iPod and the iPhone, and that of the iPad.
Thread beginning with comment 406582
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE: Turing's Poisoned Apple
by sultanqasim on Fri 29th Jan 2010 01:41 UTC in reply to "Turing's Poisoned Apple"
sultanqasim
Member since:
2006-10-28

- A Dual Core 1 GHz ARM is about 2x faster than a 1.66 GHz atom

- It can't run OSX apps, but those aren't really meant to work well on netbooks either (netbooks have even lower res screen and are much slower). It is less capable, but netbooks don't really run "real" apps like photoshop or visual studio or heavy games well. The iPad can run apps for most things most people do better than any ($300-$1200) netbook (i.e. reading websites, with easy zoom and changing of orientation for the small screen, or going though tons of photos or emails with a multi touch screen instead of an unusable mini trackpad)

- It doesn't fit in your pocket, but its small enough to hold without feeling that you're lugging a laptop in your palm

- The device is a portable computer/media device, with a eBook feature. Would you want to watch videos or look at photos on a kindle screen?

- There are 'pens' for multitouch screens available if you like to write by hand, and handwriting apps will appear soon. Good touch screen keyboards are not bad as they may seem. The keys in the iPad are reasonable size (same size as netbook keyboards) and you can use the keyboard attachment if you want a full size keyboard. You will need an attachment if you want a full size keyboard on a netbook too.

Do Kindles excite you enough to make you even think about them? Over $250 for a single purpose book reader when even an iPod that costs less can do much more? The iPad isn't perfect but it's the most desirable tablet ever made so far.

Reply Parent Score: 3

RE[2]: Turing's Poisoned Apple
by Laurence on Fri 29th Jan 2010 02:16 in reply to "RE: Turing's Poisoned Apple"
Laurence Member since:
2007-03-26


- It can't run OSX apps, but those aren't really meant to work well on netbooks either


What about other tablet/slate PCs though?
As this device is competing with them too.



(netbooks have even lower res screen and are much slower).

I think you've been looking at the bottem end of the market too much.
There's plenty of devices out there that can easily output 1024x768 and has the same screen size.

If you venture out of the "netbook" classification a moment but continue to look at simular devices then you'd see there's even more to choose from with devices as powerful as laptops but at the same dimensions (or marginally bigger) as netbooks.


It is less capable, but netbooks don't really run "real" apps like photoshop or visual studio or heavy games well.

Tablet and Slate PCs do though.
And there is a whole golf of applications between photoshop and whatever social networking frontends are popular on the iPhone.

One of my closest mates does ALL of his web development on his netbook.

My missus uses hers to write up lesson plans for the classes she teaches (if she tried to do that on a touch screen she'd quickly throw the device out of the window!)


The iPad can run apps for most things most people do better than any ($300-$1200) netbook (i.e. reading websites, with easy zoom and changing of orientation for the small screen, or going though tons of photos or emails with a multi touch screen instead of an unusable mini trackpad)

again, at a much higher price and again, your vastly under estimating what many people DO do on their netbooks.


- It doesn't fit in your pocket, but its small enough to hold without feeling that you're lugging a laptop in your palm

So where are you going to put it when you're not holding it?
In a bag? Oh well, you may as well have taken a proper fully functional (albeit compact) PC then.


- The device is a portable computer/media device, with a eBook feature.

You can read eBooks on netbooks and tablets/slates if you wanted to.
Most people don't though because backlit screens are a PITA compared to eInk or real printed media.


Good touch screen keyboards are not bad as they may seem.


touch screen keyboards are TERRIBLE. They're not even a close approximation to a hardware keyboard.
No matter how big you make the graphics, it's still not tactile. And that will always be their fundamental downfall.
Software keyboards are also a good way to induce RSI or other typing injuries as there's no cushion for your finger tips

The keys in the iPad are reasonable size (same size as netbook keyboards)

The sole reason I didn't buy an iPhone was because I just couldn't get to grips with it's keyboard.

I don't look at the keyboard as I type normally, so why should I have to on my mobile devices just because Apple have an inherent disliking of buttons?

and you can use the keyboard attachment if you want a full size keyboard.

Extra stuff to carry around. I've already addressed this point and why it's impractical.

You will need an attachment if you want a full size keyboard on a netbook too.

It's not the size that matters - it's the fact that it's tactile.
You can feel your way around the keys and instantly know when you've missed a button or can feel where your hands are on the keys (as in which letter) without having to look down every 5 seconds.

Do Kindles excite you enough to make you even think about them?

I don't read much - so personally no. But I'm not Kindles target audience either.

Over $250 for a single purpose book reader when even an iPod that costs less can do much more?

You're forgetting about the Android eBook readers ;)

The iPad isn't perfect but it's the most desirable tablet ever made so far.

Desirable if you take form over function. Personally I don't. Personally I was hoping for something special but this isn't it.

Personally, I think the tablet market is still wide open.

Reply Parent Score: 2

sultanqasim Member since:
2006-10-28

Then the iPad's not for you. Just because it doesn't do what you want doesn't mean its a bad device. Name a single hand holdable tablet with a Pixel Qi touchscreen and tactile keyboard with decent battery life, viewing angle, speed, that runs windows, and costs under $1000. If one exists, please tell me about it.

Reply Parent Score: 2

RE[2]: Turing's Poisoned Apple
by _txf_ on Fri 29th Jan 2010 02:22 in reply to "RE: Turing's Poisoned Apple"
_txf_ Member since:
2008-03-17

-That keyboard definitely sucks. It is absolute insanity to expect essays or even a medium sized email to be typed up on this thing. It isn't about the size but about the more direct feedback you get from pressing keys and not to mention the shock absorption that comes from pressing buttons.

-There are no apps and no methods to deal with direct input from a pen (specifically designed for it or no).
So some enterprising developer comes along and says yup I have a pen based handwriting solution but i need to sell the pen and install drivers....wait not gonna happen because apple will probably deny it in the app store, let alone trying to install it by other means.

Managing documents is a no go as this device needs to b-e synced (no file manager here).

-It is too expensive to be used in education, which requires much more flexibility in a device...for starters the ability to install educational software.

-What the device does do well is play and view APPLE'S MEDIA because I can't see apple allowing any old format to work with this thing.
For audio it isn't that big a deal due to the ubiquity of mp3, ease and speed of transcoding etc. But for video it is plain silly as video takes too long to transcode and the market is too fractured under competing implementations e.g. hulu,itunes netflix and not to mention divx etc.

Reply Parent Score: 2

sultanqasim Member since:
2006-10-28

I agree that a tactile keyboard is ergonomically better than a touchscreen, but use a larger touchscreen for a day and you'll find its not half as bad as you felt it was at first. I could barely type a word when I first tried an iPhone but within 15 minutes, I was able to do 15 wpm with my thumb on that tiny keyboard. I'm certain a larger one would be much easier.

Format support for media is quite wide, and transcoding doesn't take that long on a modern computer. It's absurd to suggest that it doesn't support non-apple media.

It does support any software in the app store, including educational apps.

No drivers are needed for the multi touch styluses, and there are already handwriting recognition apps in the app store (e.g. WritePad).

One area I where strongly agree with you is the need for a File Manager. If you plan on making many documents, it'll be much better to have a centralized file manager rather than having a unique list of documents for each app. Support for wireless file transfer will be good to. For now, Olive Toast's Files will have to do, but a proper integrated file manager would be much preferred [provided that it's not crippled in some way].

Reply Parent Score: 2