Linked by Andrew Hudson on Tue 23rd Feb 2010 00:23 UTC
Thread beginning with comment 410465
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE[3]: All very nice...
by umccullough on Tue 23rd Feb 2010 03:47
in reply to "RE[2]: All very nice..."
If their hardware support is better than I thought, perhaps they need to make it clearer what the current state of things is...
No, not yet. Not for an alpha-quality OS. And precisely to avoid having a whole bunch of people with modern proprietary hardware lacking open specifications from whining about their hardware not working when they thought it would.
Haiku is in a state of heavy testing/development still. If you're not willing to "try" it without getting an explicit written guarantee in advance that you'll receive a certain "experience", then I think it's wrong for you. Please move along now.
Haiku is in a state of heavy testing/development still. If you're not willing to "try" it without getting an explicit written guarantee in advance that you'll receive a certain "experience", then I think it's wrong for you. Please move along now.
Meanwhile, posting your "impression" based upon zero real-life experience, isn't going to help. Perhaps you should consider silence, or -questions- instead of statements full of unfounded, sweeping generalizations.
Oh wait, this is the internet. Most of us are stupid.
Edited 2010-02-23 04:05 UTC
No, not yet. Not for an alpha-quality OS. And precisely to avoid having a whole bunch of people with modern proprietary hardware lacking open specifications from whining about their hardware not working when they thought it would.
I agree. But that is still a real concern.
Two things I have said in the past about Haiku and OSNews: focus on the fundamentals and drop that extravagant advocacy.
If an OS hasn't even reached one release, it can not be "mature" or "stable". The status of "mature" is reached after years -- and decades. Keep the alpha-status bravely and keep experimenting, but do not try to go fishing to areas which clearly are not the core strengths. You don't need that much advocacy: those that want to code, find your system without it.
(And well, this is the destiny of any "alternative operating system". You get a thousand and one Linux people -- you know, those pretending to be "open-minded" -- bitching about things that do not work compared to their system that is developed by corporate overloads; probably the same people who have never contributed code but think that contributing noise is the same thing.)
RE[3]: All very nice...
by Valhalla on Wed 24th Feb 2010 12:08
in reply to "RE[2]: All very nice..."




Member since:
2008-08-19
Did you even try a build of Haiku on your hardware?
No, because the information I can find on their website suggests there's not much point. Perhaps it's incorrect, but my comments were based on recent (i.e this year) posts in their forums indicating that while traditional SMP worked fine, multi-core didn't. Likewise, my comments about WiFi or video support come from the Haiku site and forums.
If their hardware support is better than I thought, perhaps they need to make it clearer what the current state of things is...