Linked by Thom Holwerda on Thu 13th May 2010 18:39 UTC, submitted by hotice
Gnome The problem with just about every virtual desktop implementation is just that - they're virtual. This means that beyond the ability to move windows to specific desktops, you're still looking at exactly the same desktop, no matter what virtual desktop number you switched to. A mockup for GNOME Shell is trying to take the virtual out of virtual desktop.
Thread beginning with comment 424270
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE: Comment by phoenix
by WereCatf on Thu 13th May 2010 21:40 UTC in reply to "Comment by phoenix"
WereCatf
Member since:
2006-02-15

Wow! What a horrible way to do things. Instead of forcing the filesystem to fit the window manager, why not add the ability to point the "view" at any folder?

You're missing the point: the KDE4 approach is all manual and not that easily accessible to complete newbies. The GNOME approach is all automated and as such much more beneficial to a larger audience. Of course they could add the ability of pointing the desktop to one or another folder manually, but it'd still have to automatically create and manage those folders for those desktops which do not have a manually set destination.

"and here they are trying to re-create that feature in the most god-awful way possible."

That's your opinion. I actually see it as they taking the KDE4 idea and improving it.

Reply Parent Score: 4

RE[2]: Comment by phoenix
by phoenix on Thu 13th May 2010 21:55 in reply to "RE: Comment by phoenix"
phoenix Member since:
2005-07-11

"Wow! What a horrible way to do things. Instead of forcing the filesystem to fit the window manager, why not add the ability to point the "view" at any folder?

You're missing the point: the KDE4 approach is all manual and not that easily accessible to complete newbies.


How is it not easily accessible? It's a folder view, as in "see the contents of a folder". By default, there's one folder view that shows the contents of the ~/Desktop folder, just like the default desktop everywhere. Want something different? It's a click away.

I have a desktop displaying 4 different folder views. How does one do that in GNOME?

I can setup 4 virtual desktops, each showing a different folder, without being locked into some horrible ~/Desktop1 ~/Desktop2 mess (or ~/Desktop/Work ~/Desktop/Whatever mess).

Forcing the filesystem to match a single window manager is just wrong. Period.

The GNOME approach is all automated and as such much more beneficial to a larger audience. Of course they could add the ability of pointing the desktop to one or another folder manually, but it'd still have to automatically create and manage those folders for those desktops which do not have a manually set destination.


Or, make it even simpler and make it configurable from the get-go.

[q]"and here they are trying to re-create that feature in the most god-awful way possible."


That's your opinion. I actually see it as they taking the KDE4 idea and improving it.
"

To each their own, but I still fail to see how forcing a user's filesystem hierarchy to fit a single WM is "improving" anything.

Reply Parent Score: 2

RE[3]: Comment by phoenix
by Yagami on Thu 13th May 2010 22:58 in reply to "RE[2]: Comment by phoenix"
Yagami Member since:
2006-07-15

wow ... i just wow !!!

kde's aseigo has been saying that for years and people burned him for it.

THAT WAS THE WHOLE POINT of creating the folder view , and not making the default activity with the "desktop folder", but having the folder you wanted , or even more than one folder

Reply Parent Score: 2