Linked by Jordan Spencer Cunningham on Mon 14th Jun 2010 23:58 UTC
Thread beginning with comment 430139
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
"...and it's worst than installing manually software YOU chose to install because you TRUST the repository of the linux distribution.
I fail to see how it's worse than installing software manually. Debian users got an OpenSSL security update as soon as the vulnerability was patched, because it was in the repository. In fact, not only did it fix the vulnerability, but there were several layers of safety in the patch to identify weak keys and warn the user if they are present, as well as stopping any of the same keys from coincidentally being generated in the future (because any attacker would look for the known weak keys first). The Debian vulnerability was caused by human error, not by malicious intent as we've seen in the UnrealIRC problem. One flaw doesn't prove that the system is broken. Multiple flaws do. Internet Explorer 6 isn't broken because of a cross-site-scripting flaw discovered in 2006, it's broken because people keep finding cross-site-scripting flaws in it. The same applies with the repositories. " Once again, with emphasis, this UnrealIRCd problem has absolutely nothing to do with the repository system.
UnrealIRCd didn't use the repository system, and THAT was the problem.




Member since:
2008-05-26
I fail to see how it's worse than installing software manually. Debian users got an OpenSSL security update as soon as the vulnerability was patched, because it was in the repository. In fact, not only did it fix the vulnerability, but there were several layers of safety in the patch to identify weak keys and warn the user if they are present, as well as stopping any of the same keys from coincidentally being generated in the future (because any attacker would look for the known weak keys first).
The Debian vulnerability was caused by human error, not by malicious intent as we've seen in the UnrealIRC problem.
One flaw doesn't prove that the system is broken. Multiple flaws do. Internet Explorer 6 isn't broken because of a cross-site-scripting flaw discovered in 2006, it's broken because people keep finding cross-site-scripting flaws in it. The same applies with the repositories.