Linked by David Adams on Fri 18th Jun 2010 19:17 UTC
Thread beginning with comment 430557
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Different isn't good enough. Ultimately, I'd hope the goal is to surpass OS X, but in order to surpass it, it must first be equalled. I like global menu bars, I like application-centric window management, I like an interface that works whether you have fifteen mouse buttons or just one. On the other hand, I grant you the dock - it's a usability nightmare, drastically overdue for a ground-up rewrite.
RE[2]: Come on People
by Bill Shooter of Bul on Fri 18th Jun 2010 23:08
in reply to "RE: Come on People"
Can we come up with something besides ripping off OSX? That Screenshot looks identical to 10.6, even the icons are clones of the Mac.
It probably goes for the same look, but it's far from identical.
In any case, the elementary project is more than just about the looks - it also aims to improve some aspects of software that are ignored by upstream developers (such as with the case of nautilus). It aims at making the linux desktop refined and coherent.
The only thing keeping me from running a linux desktop is the lack of attention, polish, and elegance to UI details in the major DE's, and linux desktop applications. It seems that some linux devs (and users) don't care about such things. The elementary project does, though.
Oh, and stop focusing on the theme for gods sake.
Edited 2010-06-19 01:23 UTC
Maybe not identical, but certainly derivative.
http://i.imgur.com/xzZwb.jpg
That's pretty bad. I'm looking to STOP using OS X in the home -- Everything at work is FBSD and Linux and I've been using FBSD since the 90s in one form or another. This is not what I want to see when I finally pull the trigger.




Member since:
2008-10-28
Can we come up with something besides ripping off OSX? That Screenshot looks identical to 10.6, even the icons are clones of the Mac. Apple Computer...err sorry "Apple, Inc." is not the end all of UI design. Some people don't like how the top and bottom panels work in GNOME but at least its something different from some candy coated dock that looks great for the first year and then just becomes annoying to use. (dock icons bounce in my nightmares)