Linked by David Adams on Tue 3rd Aug 2010 16:05 UTC, submitted by sjvn
Linux As we mentioned in a previous article, Red Hat advocate Greg DeKoenigsberg claimed that due to the much larger amount of code it's contributed, Red Hat is a better open source citizen than Canonical, adding, "Canonical is a marketing organization masquerading as an engineering organization." A Computerworld blog retorts that that's no insult; and that marketing Linux could be just as important to the cause as contributing code. Updated
Thread beginning with comment 435458
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
ichi
Member since:
2007-03-06

The corporate world has completely ignored Ubuntu in case you hadn't noticed.


Pretty much no other company has put a serious effort on pushing the Linux desktop, so while Ubuntu hasn't succeeded on the corporate world it has helped Linux grow in mind share.

I don't think that's something that hurts Linux.

Reply Parent Score: 2

jbauer Member since:
2005-07-06

Pretty much no other company has put a serious effort on pushing the Linux desktop, so while Ubuntu hasn't succeeded on the corporate world it has helped Linux grow in mind share.


Which is fantastic, if you only care about buzz and winning contests in Google Trends. Hype will only take you so far though and it hasn't exactly meant success in the consumer space either.

They're still relatively newcomers but it will be hard to justify the Ubuntu hype a few years from now. It should be pretty obvious by now that something more than lots of buzz is needed, and in my opinion whoever thinks that things are gonna change significantly and users are gonna flood to Ubuntu (or any other Linux for that matter) is only kidding himself.

Reply Parent Score: 3

vivainio Member since:
2008-12-26

It should be pretty obvious by now that something more than lots of buzz is needed, and in my opinion whoever thinks that things are gonna change significantly and users are gonna flood to Ubuntu (or any other Linux for that matter) is only kidding himself.


Thinks are going to change significantly. It might take 10 years, but that's no problem because financial problems or failure to gain mindshare in short term are not real problems for Linux as a whole.

Linux is pretty much unstoppable. And it's only going to win more when people shift more and more to different form factors (phones and tablets).

Reply Parent Score: 4

ichi Member since:
2007-03-06

Which is fantastic, if you only care about buzz and winning contests in Google Trends. Hype will only take you so far though and it hasn't exactly meant success in the consumer space either.


The thing is, partially because of Canonical's marketing, people at least know about Linux, which puts it closer to any kind of adoption that the previous "Linux? WTF is that?".

Linux marketshare won't skyrocket (or even grow significantly, or at all, or whatever) just because of Ubuntu, but you wouldn't ever get there anyway if people doesn't even know Linux exists.

Rather than complaining about Canonical being code leeches, other companies should capitalize on Ubuntu's marketing work same as Canonical takes advantage of the development efforts of RedHat and the likes.

RedHat isn't even trying to push Linux on the desktop, so why are they angry about Ubuntu taking all the (so to speak) glory? If they want the mind share then start placing ads, sending CDs and making deals with OEMs.

Reply Parent Score: 2