Linked by Thom Holwerda on Sun 19th Sep 2010 21:18 UTC, submitted by gireesh
Mandriva, Mandrake, Lycoris It's been a troubling couple of weeks for Mandriva, but I decided not to report on it since I found it hard to unravel the events leading up to all this. Now, though, the story has come to its (logical) conclusion: now that most of Mandriva's employees have been laid off, they came together and forked Mandriva. Enter Mageia.
Thread beginning with comment 441695
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE[2]: Argh, so unfair...
by djame on Sun 19th Sep 2010 23:04 UTC in reply to "RE: Argh, so unfair..."
djame
Member since:
2005-07-08

"but what incompetence ? on generating less reviews, yes certainly.


How about wholly incompetent at running a business?
"

You mean how about bashing them for failing where redhat, suse, xendros, linwin, gentoo and I can't remember who else failed as well ?
Come on, you know well that without the unlimited funding brought to ubuntu, there will be on the list too.

The problem is not on on how to build the best distro out there but how to build a successfull business model where "customer"'s alpha and omega seems to be "I want the best, I want it now and for free as in speech and as in beer. Please, I'm hurry otherwise I'll get your distro on bittorent and that's it"
So speaking of the incompetence of people who just tried everything as everyone else did is a bit unfair to me. it's like telling to people who can't fly that they suck big time because they can't do as well as superman or as the next billionaire who got some wings greffed on his back.

Edited 2010-09-19 23:06 UTC

Reply Parent Score: 9

RE[3]: Argh, so unfair...
by sultanqasim on Mon 20th Sep 2010 01:19 in reply to "RE[2]: Argh, so unfair..."
sultanqasim Member since:
2006-10-28

Overall I agree with you comment, but I won't call RedHat a failure. They are a profitable company who build a solid product and earn hundreds of millions every year.

Reply Parent Score: 2

RE[4]: Argh, so unfair...
by djame on Mon 20th Sep 2010 01:22 in reply to "RE[3]: Argh, so unfair..."
djame Member since:
2005-07-08

Overall I agree with you comment, but I won't call RedHat a failure. They are a profitable company who build a solid product and earn hundreds of millions every year.


Sorry, I was talking about the desktop part of their activity. Now it's almost completely community driven in the Fedora project.

Reply Parent Score: 1

RE[3]: Argh, so unfair...
by google_ninja on Mon 20th Sep 2010 14:11 in reply to "RE[2]: Argh, so unfair..."
google_ninja Member since:
2006-02-05

so your argument is that since the business plan was impossible, the pursuit of the impossible shows competence in the management?

Part of being a good entrepreneur is knowing when to stop wasting your (and your investors) time and money, and move on to something that makes more sense.

Reply Parent Score: 3

RE[4]: Argh, so unfair...
by djame on Mon 20th Sep 2010 14:24 in reply to "RE[3]: Argh, so unfair..."
djame Member since:
2005-07-08

[q]so your argument is that since the business plan was impossible, the pursuit of the impossible shows competence in the management? /q]
no, I've never said that. I said that failing was not a sign of incompetence, therefore bashing them for that is just pointless.

Reply Parent Score: 1

RE[4]: Argh, so unfair...
by spiderman on Mon 20th Sep 2010 18:22 in reply to "RE[3]: Argh, so unfair..."
spiderman Member since:
2008-10-23

so your argument is that since the business plan was impossible, the pursuit of the impossible shows competence in the management?

Part of being a good entrepreneur is knowing when to stop wasting your (and your investors) time and money, and move on to something that makes more sense.

Except Mandriva is not a waste of money.
Maybe they didn't find a good business model, maybe it does not exist but Mandriva is definitely not a waste of money. They've moved the desktop forward and that is a great achievement. Making money is a necessary step to achieve their goals but their goal is not to make money. Maybe they didn't make enough money but the money they made has moved the dektop forward. Even if they can't make it any further they still had success.
"sense" != "money"

Reply Parent Score: 3

RE[3]: Argh, so unfair...
by Soulbender on Mon 20th Sep 2010 15:24 in reply to "RE[2]: Argh, so unfair..."
Soulbender Member since:
2005-08-18

for failing where redhat, suse, xendros, linwin, gentoo and I can't remember who else failed as well ?


Redhat and SUSE is still around and gentoo isn't a for-profit operation. As for Xandros and Linwin, well yeah,I guess they weren't good enough businessmen either.

The problem is not on on how to build the best distro out there but how to build a successfull business model


So you're saying that Mandriva's management is competent even though it didn't manage to create a sustainable business model? Hmmm....

So speaking of the incompetence of people who just tried everything as everyone else did is a bit unfair to me.


If everyone else has already failed maybe it's not the right thing to try. Again, that's what competent management is supposed to be able to figure out.

Edit: Ok, you're trying to say that failure != incompetence. Sure, but if you fail for an extended period of time with everything you try incompetence might be part of the problem.

Edited 2010-09-20 15:28 UTC

Reply Parent Score: 2

RE[4]: Argh, so unfair...
by djame on Mon 20th Sep 2010 16:42 in reply to "RE[3]: Argh, so unfair..."
djame Member since:
2005-07-08

please if you're quoting me use full sentences otherwise people will think you're trying to have a point by extracting things out of their context.

Reply Parent Score: 1