Linked by Thom Holwerda on Mon 22nd Nov 2010 19:55 UTC, submitted by Michael
Thread beginning with comment 450865
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.




Member since:
2005-07-12
I don't like Phoronix. So often, it seems that they don't understand what they are benchmarking. I'd imagine the discussion to benchmark ZFS went something like this.
"Hey. I've got an idea. I just got my hands on a pre-release ZFS Linux module that nobody else has access to. Let's benchmark it!"
"Well, we don't have a test system that's at all representative of what people who need ZFS would be using. I mean, it's only got half the ram that an actual production system might be using at an absolute minimum. Plus, our benchmarks don't run continuously, so the heavy amount of caching that ZFS does won't be utilized, skewing results in a dis-favorable manner. Never mind that this is early code that hasn't even been released yet."
"Yeah, but, people won't realize that until they click through a large amount of pages, each crammed full of as much advertising as possible."
...
Why did they only include Solaris on a couple of tests? They don't say.