Linked by Thom Holwerda on Sat 27th Nov 2010 10:46 UTC
Legal The US is really ramping up its war on intellectual property infringement, a war which I'm sure will be just as successful, cheap and supported by the people as the wars on drugs and terrorism. The US has started seizing the domain names of various websites through ICANN - not because owners of these sites were convicted of anything, but merely because complaints have been filed against them. Anyone want to take a guess how long it will be before the US government blocks WikiLeaks? Update: The blocks function outside of the US too. In other words, the US is forcing its views upon the rest of the world once again.
Thread beginning with comment 451407
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE[5]: Correction
by MollyC on Sun 28th Nov 2010 02:45 UTC in reply to "RE[4]: Correction"
MollyC
Member since:
2006-07-04

Frankenfuss is using the term "steal", colloquially. Steal means more than your legal definition of "theft" as it is used in common language. For example, the term "stealing cable" has been widely accepted to mean the act of getting cable TV signals for free without authorization.

Anyway, when people get hung up over the word "steal" when it comes to piracy, I at times will use the word "cheat" instead. Pirates of IP are cheating the creators out of rightful payment, just like one who sneaks into a movie theater to watch a movie for free is cheating the movie theater out of rightful payment.

So I will alter Frankenfuss's original post, thusly:
It's amazing how people here will defend to the death their alleged inalienable right to CHEAT others.

People don't like to be cheated any more than they like to be stolen from. And cheating can be worse than stealing; it depends on the nature of the cheating.

Reply Parent Score: 3

RE[6]: Correction
by ricegf on Sun 28th Nov 2010 03:08 in reply to "RE[5]: Correction"
ricegf Member since:
2007-04-25

Frankenfuss is using the term "steal", colloquially.


Possibly, but he did put the word in all caps and then reinforce that use with synonyms. And language is important, particularly in this case where "STEAL" and "thievery" have very different connotations than "copyright infringement".

Nor are Big Media's estimates of lost revenue from copyright infringement even vaguely credible.

So I stand firmly by my post. It's "copyright infringement", not "thievery" or "cheating" or the even more amusing "piracy". Arrrr.

Reply Parent Score: 3

RE[6]: Correction
by Valhalla on Sun 28th Nov 2010 14:03 in reply to "RE[5]: Correction"
Valhalla Member since:
2006-01-24

For example, the term "stealing cable" has been widely accepted to mean the act of getting cable TV signals for free without authorization.

And where did this term originate? I'm guessing it was coined by cable companies or reporters, not by ordinary man who I am certain will call it something like 'getting cable for free'. And again in this case it's not stealing, it's accessing something which you have not paid to access.

As for people copying stuff they have no right of copying. I don't know, but I think we as a people reap what we sow. There's a celebration of utter greed in this world, and the corruption in our governments show us that those who are supposed to lead us by example live by the 'grab what you can when you can' principle.

People see their taxes go to saving banks which have lost their money through massive gamblings again in the name of greed. Why would this coming generation feel any reason to 'do the right thing'? I sure as hell can't blame them for copying what they can and use their money on things they can't copy when everyone at the top is grabbing all they can without shame.

What goes around comes around.

Reply Parent Score: 4

RE[7]: Correction
by WorknMan on Sun 28th Nov 2010 14:36 in reply to "RE[6]: Correction"
WorknMan Member since:
2005-11-13

As for people copying stuff they have no right of copying. I don't know, but I think we as a people reap what we sow. There's a celebration of utter greed in this world, and the corruption in our governments show us that those who are supposed to lead us by example live by the 'grab what you can when you can' principle.


Well, you got the first part right... as a people, we reap what we sow. We are a corrupt and greedy society, and so we elect corrupt and greedy politicians. That stuff starts from the bottom up, not from the top down. The corrupt politicians of the future are the same ones right now who are leeching off of their neighbor's cable and/or broadband internet connection. It's not like people are turned to the dark side as soon as they get elected...

Why would this coming generation feel any reason to 'do the right thing'? I sure as hell can't blame them for copying what they can and use their money on things they can't copy when everyone at the top is grabbing all they can without shame.


As I said above, if we all choose to be crooked like those who are in power, those of us who eventually make it to the top will be the same way; it's like families who have 4-5 generations that end up on welfare. So if we want to see REAL change, the cycle has to stop somewhere, and it can begin with us ...

Reply Parent Score: 2