Linked by Thom Holwerda on Wed 1st Dec 2010 22:45 UTC
Thread beginning with comment 452127
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE[4]: the truth is there
by dylansmrjones on Sat 4th Dec 2010 05:10
in reply to "RE[3]: the truth is there"
Anarchy have laws, and have structure. It has nothing to do with mob rule and chaos. You do not understand what anarchy is.
Anarchy is absense of State (in its centralised oppressive form), but not absense of structure, laws nor organisation. It is however voluntary organisation instead of forced organisation.
Mob rule is what you have when you have a state. USSR was a mob rule. USA is becoming one.
RE[5]: the truth is there
by Tuishimi on Sun 5th Dec 2010 00:44
in reply to "RE[4]: the truth is there"
Anarchy have laws, and have structure. It has nothing to do with mob rule and chaos. You do not understand what anarchy is.
Anarchy is absense of State (in its centralised oppressive form), but not absense of structure, laws nor organisation. It is however voluntary organisation instead of forced organisation.
Anarchy is absense of State (in its centralised oppressive form), but not absense of structure, laws nor organisation. It is however voluntary organisation instead of forced organisation.
You keep saying that. HOW is structure maintained "voluntarily"? So everyone is expected to know "the rules" and to not only obey them but enforce them? I suppose the rules would have to indicate "due process" because otherwise yeah, it is a MOB MENTALITY.





Member since:
2005-11-09
Anarchy is NOT direct democracy. Direct democracy has rules and structure. Anarchy is simple mob rule and whomever rules the mob rules. There are no laws under Anarchy and civil society cannot exist without rules. Even the most basic tribal civilization has rules. Anarchy does not fit into the picture of Human society.