To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
You seem to get lost between "It uses a modified Linux kernel" and "Android is not a Linux product". A Linux product is a product built on Linux technology. Android is. It really is just that simple. (Maybe you meant it's not a Gnu/Linux product? We'd agree there - Android has a custom user land built on Java technology. ;-)
Speaking of remarkable leaps, the thread was:
Where did you get 30% from?
"
Probably from Gartner.
[/q]
The context of my comments were about Linux on the desktop.
[/q]
Jumping from "30% in the mobile area" to "the context of my comments were about Linux on the desktop" is... well, remarkable. :-D
Please... it's beginning to get old. Nobody cares about the difference between Linux and GNU/Linux; it is good for nothing aside from making excuses and showing off. Users only care about the userland (hence the name). Since Android doesn't use the Linux userland, it is not a "Linux OS", at least not in the same way as Meego is.
Yes, but as a brand, Linux is as marginal on phones as on the desktop. It would be great if Nokia and Meego could change that.
I'm not at all lost. Android is not a "Linux product". It's a Google product.
Calling it a Linux product is about as accurate as calling a plane that uses Mercedes jet engines a Mercedes product. It may use a component of what the general person considers Linux (i.e. the userland experience), that is a modified kernel but calling it a "Linux product" is simply misleading.
erm... modified linux kernel is STILL a linux kernel. And when they say modified they mean it has things that the mainline linux kernel did not accept. But it still tracks the mainline linux kernel, patches flow easily between them and it operates in much the same way.
Also...Define "Linux Product". Who makes these mystical products, what are their characteristics?
Edited 2010-12-19 18:48 UTC





Member since:
2005-12-15
Android is not a "Linux product". It has a modified Linux kernel, among many other differences.
The context of my comments were about Linux on the desktop.