Linked by Thom Holwerda on Sat 15th Oct 2005 15:55 UTC
Windows "Today [14-10-05] just so happens to mark the third birthday of Microsoft's Media Center Edition of Windows XP, which is likely why the company is rolling out a major update to the MCE product. Dubbed Rollup 2, the update is available to current WMC customers via Windows Update. Will you want it?"
Thread beginning with comment 45635
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Dos
by on Sun 16th Oct 2005 01:51 UTC

Member since:

Apple will do it better and right. Microsoft may win by pure numbers, but Apple will win from being innovated with it and a better design.

I mean fiddle around with 100 buttons(40+) on Microsofts remote compared to under 10 on the iMac's.

Apple makes Microsoft look like they are putting a square peg in a round whole! Nice one Bill..lol!

RE: Dos
by n4cer on Sun 16th Oct 2005 02:01 in reply to "Dos "
n4cer Member since:
2005-07-06

I mean fiddle around with 100 buttons(40+) on Microsofts remote compared to under 10 on the iMac's.

Apple makes Microsoft look like they are putting a square peg in a round whole! Nice one Bill..lol!


The reason Front Row has so few buttons is because it isn't as featureful as MCE. For example, it has no TV interface, and if it did, you'd be stuck with Channel Up/Channel Down instead of being able to just directly key in the channel you want. Steve's comparison was a prime example of his usual reality distortion.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 1

RE[2]: Dos
by on Sun 16th Oct 2005 07:59 in reply to "RE: Dos "
Member since:

"Featureful" doesn't mean good. Apple have said they're successful because they think about what they should leave out, rather than what they should put in.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 0

RE: Dos
by AdamW on Sun 16th Oct 2005 06:38 in reply to "Dos "
AdamW Member since:
2005-07-06

It's already been perfectly well explained why there's only six buttons on the Mac remote. BECAUSE IT HARDLY DOES ANYTHING USEFUL. All those extra buttons on MCE remotes are not 'bloat'. They're for doing useful things that Front Row flat out doesn't do. That's like saying 'hey, my fifteen year old 13" analog TV beats your 52" HDTV because the remote has fewer buttons!!!!" Sheesh.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 1

RE[2]: Dos
by mouth on Sun 16th Oct 2005 20:58 in reply to "RE: Dos "
mouth Member since:
2005-07-06

The crappy 13" Samsung TV in my bedroom has a more intuitive remote than my 53" Hitachi HDTV in my living room. Granted, the picture is better, but the cumbersome remote and navigation system leave much to be desired. If I could somehow combine the higher quality picture with the much easier to use remote/on-screen navigation system, then I would be a very happy couch-potato!

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 1