Linked by Thom Holwerda on Thu 19th May 2011 18:59 UTC, submitted by fran
Gnome Something's - once again - brewing within the GNOME project. While a mere suggestion for now, and by no means any form of official policy, influential voices within the GNOME project are arguing that GNOME should become a full-fledged Linux-based operating system, and that the desktop environment should drop support for other operating systems such as Solaris and the BSDs. I have a feeling this isn't going to go down well with many of our readers.
Thread beginning with comment 473790
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Dilemma
by fretinator on Thu 19th May 2011 20:17 UTC
fretinator
Member since:
2005-07-06

Really quite a dilemma for me, even without this latest discussion. I've been using Linux since 1994. Currently, I don't like Gnome 3 or Unity. My experience with KDE 4 has been bad, even just a month ago with Fedora. Basically, it looks like I'm going have to try out some of the other DE's. I've used XFCE, Blackbox, and many others. I just really like some of the Gnome Applets (like Freq Scaling and the Gnome Weather applet). I may just have to use Mint or one of the others that is sticking with Gnome 2.x. However, that's probably not a good long-term plan.

It really seems like users are taking a beating these days. First they decide we don't need menus anymore. Then, the conventional taskbar/start menu is no good. It really seems like change for change's sake.

Of course, I'm old.

Reply Score: 3

RE: Dilemma
by Sauron on Thu 19th May 2011 20:32 in reply to "Dilemma"
Sauron Member since:
2005-08-02

Agree with you. The way Gnome has been heading this past year its becoming completely irrelevant for me.
Time to try out XFCE and E17 again methinks.

Reply Parent Score: 2

RE[2]: Dilemma
by danbuter on Thu 19th May 2011 20:51 in reply to "RE: Dilemma"
danbuter Member since:
2011-03-17

I've been using Xubuntu for xfce and Bodhi for e17. Both are really good distros.

Reply Parent Score: 1

RE: Dilemma
by Flatland_Spider on Fri 20th May 2011 13:59 in reply to "Dilemma"
Flatland_Spider Member since:
2006-09-01

Xfce has an applet which with run GNOME applets in the system tray, so you wouldn't miss anything.

Reply Parent Score: 1

RE[2]: Dilemma
by fretinator on Fri 20th May 2011 14:21 in reply to "RE: Dilemma"
fretinator Member since:
2005-07-06

Awesome, XFCE, here I come. I used XFCE a few time, before and after it switched to GTK. I know it has a lot of good applets itself, and I love Thunar.

I'll install it on my Laptop shortly. Thanks for the heads up!

Reply Parent Score: 2

RE: Dilemma
by Kivada on Fri 20th May 2011 16:30 in reply to "Dilemma"
Kivada Member since:
2010-07-07

Yeah, I've got that same problem, I've used almost every MS and Apple OS since DOS and the Apple IIe started using Linux in '04, I really don't like any of the new UIs coming out from anyone though, Gnome2 was IMO perfect in terms of usability and simplicity, KDE3 was good as well if using the MacOS mode, but I can't stand the mutilation of naming by sticking "K" on everything.

What I can't stand though are the new UIs like Gnome3, KDE4 and Unity, which just seem to be changing things for no real reason that benefits the USER, but I guess they do give the UI devs some reason to exist instead of moving on to something else, like oh, I dunno, building GUIs for things like the OSS GPU drivers that resemble something like AMD Catalyst Control Center/AMD Overdrive, Riva Tuner or the multitude of useful command line only tools out there that would make things easier for the non geek to use Linux and OSS software to it's fullest potential.

So now the problem is what DE should I try next? I guess I should give E17 a go, since Xfce, Lxde, IceWM, BlackBox etc all have missing features I find very useful in getting things done faster/simpler.

Reply Parent Score: 1