To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Partially true.
KDE doesn't have better integration of Gnome/GTK+ apps than Gnome has of KDE/Qt apps. But they are surely difficult to tell apart. Cross desktop integration has improved greatly in the last couple of years. When in Gnome I often mistake Qt4 applications for being GTK+ and GTK+ for being Qt when in KDE (when it was installed).
Visually KDE4 is much nicer looking than Gnome 2.x. If just that silly nepomuk-semantic-desktop-stuff would stop crashing and start being actually useful.
The KDE desktop itself is not a problem. The problem is Dolphin & Co, and the way KDE wants to be integrated tightly towards these K* apps.
KDE itself alone is a blasting desktop. But dude, using Dolphin for 5 minutes can give you a headache. Not to mention other useless K* apps. I mostly use GTK apps which are the preferred and used by millions.
The only K* app I admire is K3B. But Amarok, KSCD, and other King-kong names... I just don't choose them. Let's be sincere. Who is the one who uses KOffice here? Two people on earth?
Dolphin is a very good file manager. It can be easily configured
http://dolphin.kde.org/features.html
from a single-pane bare minimum keep-out-of-your way file manager as simplistic as Windows explorer:
http://dolphin.kde.org/images/view_mode_1.png
all the way through to a split-window, tabbed, full-featured, all-the-bling-you want mode:
http://dolphin.kde.org/images/all_features.png
As for the application names, users don't see them. On the menus, you run Dolphin by clicking on the menu entry labelled "File Manager" which comes under the "Utilities" section.
KOffice is about to be replaced, BTW, with Calligra Office 2.4 for KDE4, which is now in beta:
http://www.calligra-suite.org/
Have a look around, you might be surprised by what this new about-to-be-released Office suite can do. Calligra Office suite, BTW, is split into a core an a series of front-end UIs. Also about to be released is Calligra Active, designed to run on touchscreen tablets under Plasma Active. AFAIK this is the only free Office suite designed to run on tablets.
You don't need to run KSCD to play CDs, there are many other music player apps which you can use instead. Amarok will happily play CDs. If you don't like Amarok, run Clementine. If even Clementine is too much for you, run Bangarang.
http://www.clementine-player.org/
http://bangarangkde.wordpress.com/
If you just want a media player rather than a music collection browser, run VLC.
NOTE: many of these apps do not have a "k" in their name.
Edited 2011-10-14 00:26 UTC





Member since:
2007-02-17
KDE4 has great support for GTK applications. The look and feel GTK applications under KDE4 is such that they are indistinguishable from Qt and KDE applications at first glance.
I'll do a screenshot as proof when I get home if you like, but really, you are very much out of date, this has been fixed on KDE for ages. The only problem these days is that KDE applications look terrible under GNOME ...
KDE4 has far, far better support for and integration of GTK applications than GNOME has support for KDE/Qt applications.
As for GNOME applications (as opposed to GTK applications) such as Nautilis and Evolution ... just drop them as they bring in a whole heap of GNOME dependencies. Use Dolphin for the File Manager and Kontact or Thunderbird as your email/calendar/PIM application and you will be sweet.