Linked by Thom Holwerda on Thu 20th Oct 2011 09:31 UTC
Thread beginning with comment 493565
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE[3]: Well, this is curious
by Thom_Holwerda on Thu 20th Oct 2011 18:00
in reply to "RE[2]: Well, this is curious"
Still, the original quote was not merely "voice recognition" but "improvements to voice recognition."
Ah, not only did you ignore the rest of the quote as highlighted in another comment, you also misread the statement.
"For the rest, it was a long rundown of iOS5 features we already knew, and improvements to voice recognition - which is something WP7, Android, and every other self-respecting mobile operating system does already anyway."
What I said was: voice recognition is something other operating systems already have. "Is" is singular, and hence, refers to its singular referent, "voice recognition". For the referent to be "improvements to voice recognition" (the way you read it), the sentence would have to be worded like this:
"For the rest, it was a long rundown of iOS5 features we already knew, and improvements to voice recognition - which are things WP7, Android, and every other self-respecting mobile operating system already do anyway."
Or something like that. I guess I could've worded that differently, but then again, it looks pretty clear to me.
Edited 2011-10-20 18:01 UTC
RE[4]: Well, this is curious
by jack_perry on Fri 21st Oct 2011 00:55
in reply to "RE[3]: Well, this is curious"
"Still, the original quote was not merely "voice recognition" but "improvements to voice recognition."
Ah, not only did you ignore the rest of the quote as highlighted in another comment... "
No, I didn't. See below.
What I said was: voice recognition is something other operating systems already have.
According to Rhavyn, iOS had it, too (since 2009, so a little more than two years).
"Is" is singular, and hence, refers to its singular referent, "voice recognition".
Just as "does" is singular, even though its subject is plural? (WP7, Android, and every other self-respecting mobile OS does...)
I don't mind that your English isn't perfect, but if you want to dance a "gotcha!" on English grammar, you better not have your mistakes on full display.




Member since:
2005-07-06
I dunno, Thom; I don't use any of them. That's why I ask. Still, the original quote was not merely "voice recognition" but "improvements to voice recognition."
The original description is rather dismissive, quite frankly, & I took that at face value when reading articles that gushed over Siri. But I guess apparently Apple had something pretty neat, which WP7 and Android do not have. Otherwise, Android devs wouldn't be trying to imitate it.
I have no problems w/Android devs' imitating it, BTW -- just as I have no problems w/Apple's imitating Android's notification system. But, given that the original article wasn't a very good summary of what Apple actually had, I'm left wondering if Apple's notification system is also somehow different from Android's.
I could go out & compare devices myself, but then why should I come here & read this website?