Linked by Thom Holwerda on Tue 1st Nov 2011 21:31 UTC, submitted by Z_God
KDE Disappointed with KDE 4's performance and other shortcomings, Timothy Pearson continued KDE 3.5 development under the name Trinity. Today the first third major update of the Trinity Desktop Environment is released, providing an alternative upgrade path for KDE users who do not feel comfortable with KDE 4.
Thread beginning with comment 495316
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE[2]: What's going on?
by fepede on Wed 2nd Nov 2011 12:32 UTC in reply to "RE: What's going on?"
fepede
Member since:
2005-11-14

"It seems that the last releases of the most important DEs in the Linux world (KDE and Gnome) had a lot of criticism. These includes Unity.


If you're referring to recent DE releases (e.g., Gnome 3, KDE 4.7 and Unity) then I don't know where you've been getting your information.
"

It's not an information, it is an impression, and, you know, impressions are subjective.

Reply Parent Score: 3

RE[3]: What's going on?
by lemur2 on Thu 3rd Nov 2011 00:01 in reply to "RE[2]: What's going on?"
lemur2 Member since:
2007-02-17

"It seems that the last releases of the most important DEs in the Linux world (KDE and Gnome) had a lot of criticism. These includes Unity.
If you're referring to recent DE releases (e.g., Gnome 3, KDE 4.7 and Unity) then I don't know where you've been getting your information. " It's not an information, it is an impression, and, you know, impressions are subjective.

A lot of people's impressions are driven by what they read, they don't bother to form their own impressions.

As the grandparent poster (cmost) said:
KDE 4.7 has for the most part received raving reviews. KDE 4 is all grown up and has been a welcomed refuge for many users fleeing Gnome 3 and Unity. While KDE 4 might have been a mess at its initial few releases (4.0 through 4.3) it has greatly matured over the past two years and is now a paragon of stability and usability.


This is the reality.

However, there is a huge vested interest in disparaging KDE, and KDE4 in particular. You will find a lot of postings on the Internet disparaging KDE4. Rarely is there any actual reason given, sometimes reasons are given that are the opposite of the actual situation (such as feigned dislike of KDE menus), and often there is a vast amount of misinformation.

I have even read quite a few articles (from people who allegedly support Linux on the desktop) which bemoan the situation with GNOME and Unity, ponder the demise of Linux on the desktop because of that situation, and yet they utterly ignore KDE. Go figure.

Disparaging of KDE4 appears to be, for the most part, either astroturfing (paid-for opinion pieces pretending to be grass roots opinions) or coming from misinformed fanboys of other desktops.

The fact that there are indeed some Linux systems on which the underlying OpenGL graphics stack brings down KDE's kwin doesn't help at all. It gives the haters somewhere to start.

Edited 2011-11-03 00:12 UTC

Reply Parent Score: 1

RE[4]: What's going on?
by lucas_maximus on Thu 3rd Nov 2011 19:02 in reply to "RE[3]: What's going on?"
lucas_maximus Member since:
2009-08-18

Maybe people just don't like it because, I think the reason is that KDE 4 is kinda ugly.

I hate how all the font spacings to border spacings are not "quite right", transparency all over the shop ... with no regards to constrast, gradients everywhere on everything trying to rip off the "brushed steel look".

KDE 4, if it was a woman she would be Katie Price (aka Jordan).

If they hired a professional designer ( a proper designer not a mockup artist) with some decent classic art background and a good understanding of Typography (yes this shit is bloody important) ... I am not a designer but I know when something "looks nice" ... similarly with the new google theme ... looks tonnes better with what is just a few CSS changes.

Whether you can change this is pretty much moot IMHO ... because it is first impressions that count.

Aesthetics count and so do first impressions.

I seen you brush off the looks of a system as mainly unimportant, but "Polish" really matters in people's perception.

I recently updated a Google Maps "location finder tool" for HR, fixed a few bugs and made it look "nice" and tidy and 2 minutes after deploy had the HR manager praising my work ... all because I made it a little "nicer".

Oh and this is XFCE

http://imgur.com/Erhxf

Edited 2011-11-03 19:21 UTC

Reply Parent Score: 1