Linked by Thom Holwerda on Thu 19th Jan 2012 17:41 UTC
Thread beginning with comment 504144
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE[4]: I sympathise but..
by Tony Swash on Sun 22nd Jan 2012 13:52
in reply to "RE[3]: I sympathise but.."
No one is saying that trying different tools and new technology in education is a bad thing.
The supposition you are trying to support is that iOS is the best way to do this and will give an experience that cannot be matched by anything else. Therefore, we need to willingly accept Apple's lock-in as the price that must be paid for new educational tools.
The supposition you are trying to support is that iOS is the best way to do this and will give an experience that cannot be matched by anything else. Therefore, we need to willingly accept Apple's lock-in as the price that must be paid for new educational tools.
No. What I am saying is that the Apple, iOS. iPad route is the only route that exists as a fully featured actually existing and available system at this moment. There also doesn't seem to be any likelihood of a competing system emerging in the near future. This means accepting Apple's way of doing it happen by default. That's just the way it is.
The best way to predict and manage the future is to invent it.




Member since:
2012-01-21
No one is saying that trying different tools and new technology in education is a bad thing.
The supposition you are trying to support is that iOS is the best way to do this and will give an experience that cannot be matched by anything else. Therefore, we need to willingly accept Apple's lock-in as the price that must be paid for new educational tools.
The description and teacher's testimonial talk of access to videos, the more approachable nature of a thin tablet versus a thick textbook, the more one-on-one and interactive nature of doing the problem sets, the interest in using the different technology, etc. Not the inherent supremacy of the Apple experience.
Locking things down to one platform diminishes the ability to try more tests like this and experimenting with different methods in the future.