Linked by Thom Holwerda on Tue 24th Jan 2012 22:53 UTC, submitted by fran
Ubuntu, Kubuntu, Xubuntu As much as I dislike Unity, I commend the Ubuntu team and Shuttleworth for having the guts to try to innovate and bring the desktop forward (pretty much the exact same can be said of KDE4 and GNOME3). Shuttleworth has just announced yet another significant change for Ubuntu, and it's all about replacing the menu with a search interface dubbed the HUD.
Thread beginning with comment 504389
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Comment by Luminair
by Luminair on Tue 24th Jan 2012 23:07 UTC
Luminair
Member since:
2007-03-30

Replacing clicking with typing? They serve different, complimentary purposes, and both can be accommodated in the interface. So are these guys idiots or what?

Reply Score: 5

RE: Comment by Luminair
by 5cro7um on Wed 25th Jan 2012 07:37 in reply to "Comment by Luminair"
5cro7um Member since:
2012-01-25

Read the original article - it seem OSnews din't before paraphrasing.

What they're proposing replacing at _this_stage_ is the "tap [Alt]" to drive menus with the keyboard.

Mouse-driven menus remain - they're just providing a search-oriented interface to discover menu items when you don't know where to click. The results will show the menu option that delivers the result you're after, and then after that you're free to mouse-click away.

Replacement of the menu is on the cards - _eventually_ - but only once they come up with a suitable alternative. At the moment all that's being replaced is "tap {alt} to drive your menu via a keyboard".

Reply Parent Score: 3

RE[2]: Comment by Luminair
by cyrilleberger on Wed 25th Jan 2012 08:53 in reply to "RE: Comment by Luminair"
cyrilleberger Member since:
2006-02-01

Well the original article is unclear (for the alt-tap thing, you have to look in the comments), and in the screenshot the menu is gone, giving a false impression. but if the menu is kept, this is actually a very good idea, one that I have been thinking of implementing for Krita and never done so by lazyness. And something that is actually allready existing in many professional application, such as CAD.
However, I am unsure if simply taking the actions from the menus will be the most usefull for users. I would like to be able to do things like "blur 5px all layers" would be even better. Or "show pictures last vaccation" in a picture management application.

Reply Parent Score: 4

RE: Comment by Luminair
by 5cro7um on Wed 25th Jan 2012 07:44 in reply to "Comment by Luminair"
5cro7um Member since:
2012-01-25

@Luminair: "what"

Edited 2012-01-25 07:51 UTC

Reply Parent Score: 1

RE: Comment by Luminair
by AWdrius on Wed 25th Jan 2012 14:14 in reply to "Comment by Luminair"
AWdrius Member since:
2006-07-18

I personally like the idea. As far as I see they are not going to replace mouse driven menus yet. They are going to introduce an alternative to [ALT]+{something} here.
This reminds me of reSharper for Visual Studio. I really love it because it takes away the pain for using mouse when navigating solutions. I see similar advantage with HUD too. In my 'relax' time I really hate using touchpad on my laptop. My index finger starts to hurt after a while with all the scrubbing (-. So I welcome every solution that does not require using touchpad, trackpad, 'external' mouse and so on. IMHO keyboard should be enough for computer usage. Everything else should be just another way to achieve the same or allow non-keyboard-centric and shortcut-ignorant people to do what they want.
P.S. I know that there are applications that does not apply to this (e.g. CAD software), but I do not use them.

Reply Parent Score: 1