Linked by Thom Holwerda on Mon 9th Apr 2012 12:02 UTC
Thread beginning with comment 513278
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE[2]: QNX to FSF = HURD
by demetrioussharpe on Mon 9th Apr 2012 20:30
in reply to "RE: QNX to FSF = HURD"
I think otherwise: it's the fastest way to bury Hurd into oblivion, since QNX will swallow his few active developers if open sourced.
Either that, or bury QNX in the developmental hell that's HURD development. Injecting a working system into a broken system doesn't always yield good results. More than likely, the HURD developers would try to make QNX match the HURD philosophy, ruining QNX in the process.
RE: QNX to FSF = HURD
by Bill Shooter of Bul on Mon 9th Apr 2012 14:29
in reply to "QNX to FSF = HURD"
The problem with HURD is not the lack of a viable microkernel, its with HURD's complex design and ambitious goals combined with lack of developer resources.
In retrospect, they probably should have in the name of freedom, just done a FOSS unix-like clone. Its pretty clear the FOSS market chose that in GNU/Linux, rather than trying to realize the HURD.
RE[2]: QNX to FSF = HURD
by demetrioussharpe on Mon 9th Apr 2012 20:32
in reply to "RE: QNX to FSF = HURD"
The problem with HURD is not the lack of a viable microkernel, its with HURD's complex design and ambitious goals combined with lack of developer resources.
In retrospect, they probably should have in the name of freedom, just done a FOSS unix-like clone. Its pretty clear the FOSS market chose that in GNU/Linux, rather than trying to realize the HURD.
In retrospect, they probably should have in the name of freedom, just done a FOSS unix-like clone. Its pretty clear the FOSS market chose that in GNU/Linux, rather than trying to realize the HURD.
Right! At this stage of the game, HURD's the poster child for vaperware.
QNX is the only successful microkernal POSIX operating system. I have thought for awhile, that donating QNX to the FSF is the only way Hurd will ever become a reality.
I highly doubt QNX can be made FSF-compliant open source. It's chock-full of patented and proprietary technology (i.e. drivers).





Member since:
2009-07-08
QNX is the only successful microkernal POSIX operating system. I have thought for awhile, that donating QNX to the FSF is the only way Hurd will ever become a reality.