To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
I also find it extremely annoying that people so quickly leap from "patents are problematic" to picking a side in every patent battle and whining endlessly about the perceived bad guy. There are no winners, there are no good guys. The companies to a great extent have to fight these battles since they have to maximize shareholder value, and they have to attempt to keep a level playing field.
It is a no-brainer that Android is in perfectly legitimate patent trouble under the current system, what we learn from that is that it is the system that is flawed. Giving Google a pass to take over the mobile market without having to face patent challenges would just leave us without a level playing field, unless everyone pledges not to sue another up and comer either. Google is rather unique in that it is the largest company built on the back on what is basically a single patent, US 6,285,999, PageRank, and certainly no one else is getting into the search market by using that technique. That is not to say that Google is a bad guy either, but they, like everyone, are on both sides of the problems with patents.
Apple is not the problem, the system is. If anything the intense activity at the moment will help facilitate the system getting some much needed changes.
Apple IS part of the problem, more so than other companies, for two very valid reasons.
a) Apple is by far the largest company in this business, and thus, they have the money and power to change it - but they choose not to, and in fact, lobby laws to strengthen their ability to sue the little guys into oblivion (the recent patent "reform").
b) They are one of the most aggressive - if not the most aggressive - abuser of the system, and thus, contribute to its continued existence much more so than others.
Even within a system a company can show good faith, and as far as patents go, Google has demonstrated such faith. They have not gone on the offensive in any way, shape, or form, unlike its competitors, despite the lure to do so being quite high at this point. I'd love for them to do more to change the system, but to make it seem as if Google is just as bad as Apple [re:patents] is ridiculous, at best.
Nonsense. It's like saying that any country can't stop being an aggressor, since everyone engages in war. There is a distinction between aggression and defense.
Any company can start behaving decently, and not to engage in patents aggression and patent protection racket. Apple is one of the worst in that regard, and if anyone should stop this sheer nonsense for the benefit of the society - it's Apple.
Edited 2012-04-10 20:01 UTC





Member since:
2011-05-12
"Well, mr Wozniak, you are, technically, still an Apple employee. Shouldn't be too hard for you to get an audience with mr Cook."
He does mention that Apple are the "good guys", so it doesn't make much sense for him to talk to Tim.
I don't think any company can stop this on its own, it's how the war is fought within the patent rules. These rules need to be changed. Even if all the "normal" companies stop this patent stuff the patent trolls will still continue.