Linked by Thom Holwerda on Tue 8th May 2012 17:55 UTC
PDAs, Cellphones, Wireless This is fun. The number one iOS carrier duking it out with the company behind the world's most popular smartphone operating system. Last month, Google's lead for the Android Open Source Project, Jean-Baptiste Queru, more or less blamed carriers (see comments) for Android's upgrade woes. Yesterday, AT&T's CEO Randall Stephenson retaliated, blaming Google for the delays. And yes, Google already responded to that, too.
Thread beginning with comment 517471
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Re:
by kurkosdr on Wed 9th May 2012 18:30 UTC
kurkosdr
Member since:
2011-04-11

Sorry pal, this is not the whole story. If the carriers and OEMs are to blame for Android's upgrade problems, then why the non-carrier subsidized version of the Nexus S took so long to receive 4.0 (compared to the Galaxy Nexus)? Oh yeah, drivers ("binary blobs" as they are called in linux). There was an early 4.0 upgrade for the Nexus S, but it later got pulled because it caused driver issues. Some months after, the Nexus S finally got 4.0

We ll have to admit that Linux's "if it's not open source and in the kernel tree, it will probably break during the next upgrade" approach to drivers just isn't working for cellphones, where many drivers are proprietary. These guys need to come up with a stable ABI.

Of course, carriers and OEMs are another hoop the upgrade has to go through. IMO this upgrade thing mayhem to kill Android. Windows Phone users may not get upgraded from WP7 to WP8, but at least they will receive upgrades for WP8 for a much longer time than any Android phone will.

PS: Oh, and when Google "releases" Android, they release source only for whatever hardware the most recent Nexus has. It's up to the OEMs to adapt/rewritte the new source to the hardware their phones are running.

Edited 2012-05-09 18:35 UTC

Reply Score: 3

RE: Re:
by tonny on Thu 10th May 2012 03:28 in reply to "Re:"
tonny Member since:
2011-12-22

Even Google won't provide update for their > 2 years phone. Remember when their 3rd gen. Nexus out, the update for the 1st gen. Nexus cease to exist (they're not provided it)?
Oh, How I wish there's smartphone OS that like PC OS. Something that myself can install/uninstall.

Reply Parent Score: 1

RE[2]: Re:
by Alfman on Thu 10th May 2012 04:34 in reply to "RE: Re:"
Alfman Member since:
2011-01-28

tonny.

"Oh, How I wish there's smartphone OS that like PC OS. Something that myself can install/uninstall."

Neolander was right:
http://www.osnews.com/comments/25920

Standardization is the key to solving our platform compatibility woes, and UEFI offers just that. But it's a tragedy that standardization effort has been corrupted by corporate pressure to include subsystems carefully designed to block an owner's freedom to install his own software.


The overall collective tech industry is moving towards closed personal computing devices and giving users much less control than in the past, not more. It's scary; It's not progress. I wonder if George Orwell himself realized how much his works would foreshadow reality.

Reply Parent Score: 2