Linked by Thom Holwerda on Mon 23rd Jul 2012 21:28 UTC
Thread beginning with comment 528010
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE[5]: ClearType isn't coming back
by bouhko on Tue 24th Jul 2012 11:34
in reply to "RE[4]: ClearType isn't coming back"
RE[5]: ClearType isn't coming back
by Bill Shooter of Bul on Tue 24th Jul 2012 13:42
in reply to "RE[4]: ClearType isn't coming back"
1) Consistency of the text goes completely out of the window. I imagine that is fairly jarring to the user.
The entire display is being rotated 90! That is jarring enough to completely obscure any minor font rendering changes.
2) The font cache will have to be recreated for ClearType glyphs and non ClearType glyphs. Then the gui will also have to be redrawn with the new glyphs, etc.
How may hundreds of kilobytes would it take to have two font caches? Again the screen is being rotated 90 degrees, the entire display will have to be redrawn regardless.
Edited 2012-07-24 13:43 UTC
RE[6]: ClearType isn't coming back
by _txf_ on Tue 24th Jul 2012 14:19
in reply to "RE[5]: ClearType isn't coming back"
The entire display is being rotated 90! That is jarring enough to completely obscure any minor font rendering changes.
So one way the fonts look good and the other look less good? What is the point of rotating the display, as people will only ever use it in the better looking orientation?
Minor changes in fonts tend to be easily detected and I'd hypothesize that most people would prefer to get used to a single less good (but consistent) representation as opposed to two differing representations of the same text. It would be an interesting test to try.
How may hundreds of kilobytes would it take to have two font caches? Again the screen is being rotated 90 degrees, the entire display will have to be redrawn regardless.
In many cases the screen only has to be composited again upon rotation(textures scaled or moved around). But often text will have to be reflowed (in large documents), so it is as you say (redrawn anyway). Two font caches are slightly more inefficient though.





Member since:
2008-03-17
1) Consistency of the text goes completely out of the window. I imagine that is fairly jarring to the user.
2) The font cache will have to be recreated for ClearType glyphs and non ClearType glyphs. Then the gui will also have to be redrawn with the new glyphs, etc.