Linked by Thom Holwerda on Fri 27th Jul 2012 12:41 UTC
Gnome Honest question. Do you think the GNOME project is as healthy today as it was, say, 4 years ago? Benjamin Otte explains that no, it isn't. GNOME lacks developers, goals, mindshare and users. The situation as he describes it, is a lot more dire than I personally thought.
Thread beginning with comment 528561
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Shame, I like gnome3
by Bill Shooter of Bul on Fri 27th Jul 2012 19:23 UTC
Bill Shooter of Bul
Member since:
2006-07-14

It really feels more modern and usable to me than gnome 2 does. I've unleashed complete newbies into gnome 3 gui and they didn't skip a beat. gnome 2 gave the same users some pause and took them a while to figure things out.

Having said that, I understand most users complaints about gnome 3. It takes a different mindset to use, or a ton of extensions. Most people don't want to completely rethink how they use their desktops. And honestly it isn't dramatically better after you do. I just like doing things differently from time to time. So I do switch between KDE4 and gnome. when I get a chance I'll give cinnamon a try too...

Reply Score: 3

RE: Shame, I like gnome3
by snowbender on Fri 27th Jul 2012 21:20 in reply to "Shame, I like gnome3"
snowbender Member since:
2006-05-04

I've unleashed complete newbies into gnome 3 gui and they didn't skip a beat. gnome 2 gave the same users some pause and took them a while to figure things out.


This hints that gnome 3 is written for complete newbies?

I use linux since 1997. As a window manager in the beginning I used mainly WindowMaker and XFCE3. Then I started using Garnome, which if I remember it right, was a script to build Gnome 2 from trunk. And in any case, I've used Gnome 2 for a very long time.

Since a couple of years, I feel left behind as a faithful linux user. Everything in the linux world lately seems to be targetted at Windows users. Every piece of software seems to be targetted at new inexperienced users. The whole Gnome 3 seems to be targetted at new inexperienced users. Every single piece of software seems to be so dumbed down.

In my eyes, the Gnome developers are targetting a group of people that currently do not, and most likely will not use Gnome. Let me give you a clue: most of those people currently use Windows or OSX and are perfectly happy with those systems. Why would they change? Why would you try to make them change?

The Gnome developers seem to be focussed so much on attracting new users, that they completely ignored the existing user base of experienced linux power users...

Either way.. I switched to XFCE4 in the mean time... which I'm not exactly very happy with, but it works.

Some other people mentioned that some desktop environments have been using methods and idioms that are over 20 years old and that those never changed and that there should be more evolution in the software. Let me tell you this... if those methods and idioms have been in use over the whole world for over 20 years and people are generally happy with those idioms, then it probably means that there must be something good about them.

Reply Parent Score: 7

RE[2]: Shame, I like gnome3
by bouhko on Fri 27th Jul 2012 22:13 in reply to "RE: Shame, I like gnome3"
bouhko Member since:
2010-06-24

I think you raise a very valid point. Gnome 3 is targeted towards non-technical users. That's one of the reason why they have close to zero customization and stuff.

The problem is that once you get out of the Gnome reality distortion field, the people who use GNU/Linux on the desktop are technical people. Linux desktop is mostly very popular amongst engineers and scientists. Those are mostly people who just want a UI that works and don't care much about all the fancy stuff.
Now, it's good to try to make an interface that's more welcoming to new users, but they should do that without alienating their existing userbase.

Reply Parent Score: 3

Bill Shooter of Bul Member since:
2006-07-14

Well, I didn't exactly mean that it was directed towards newbies. But it doesn't surprise me that they would have a better time picking it up and accepting it than those that were used to gnome 2.

Its different. I'm not saying that the complaints aren't valid, because they kind of are. It sucks when someone takes something you have configured perfectly for your usage and messes it all up. Having said that, there is a certain challenge in learning new ways of doing things that is exciting. Obviously those complaining don't relish that challenge. Which is ironic, because I had thought that challenge was what drove many people to Linux in the first place.

I do believe some of my friends mocked me as a newbie because I used gnome/kde instead of all command line.

Reply Parent Score: 2

RE: Shame, I like gnome3
by Yoko_T on Wed 1st Aug 2012 23:15 in reply to "Shame, I like gnome3"
Yoko_T Member since:
2011-08-18

It really feels more modern and usable to me than gnome 2 does. I've unleashed complete newbies into gnome 3 gui and they didn't skip a beat. gnome 2 gave the same users some pause and took them a while to figure things out.


Who *ARE* these people? Your inbred cousins living in the mountains of West Virginia?

Reply Parent Score: 1